Ad: This forum contains affiliate links to products on Amazon and eBay. More information in Terms and rules
No not perhaps the germans had 12000 tons of war workable tabunGermany could answer with nerve gas? Perhaps.
But the Allies also could trow nerve gas in the German cities trough bombing.
I'm not saying that the USAAF should not have choose the P-51 (the proposed is that it was not developed). As for the P-51 being "crucial", crucial is one thing, while absolutely crucial is other.
DonL, if Germany was to be nuked, it would not be with one bomb per time like Japan, it would probably be by several simultaneously.
Stona I have not the knowledge about allied B weapons but to my sources they had a large stockpile of C-weapons inclusive bombs.
Ok it is realy off topic but the A-Bomb on Germany is something what comes up pretty regular.
How do you figure?
All this fighting, all this fighting ... you see ... that's why the P-51 is NOT my favorite WW2 fighter .... people always get into fights about how good it is! Give me Mr. Fat Reliable from Republic with air con and a cigar lighter in the dash. Built for comfort ....
MM
I have to agree the P51 was one of the most critical aircraft. The P38 at the time didn't have the range, it had problems at altitude in Europe and I have never heard of the Germans being overawed by its combat performance.This is not a what if thread. The P-51 was developed.
So how was the P-51 not one of the 10 most crucial aircraft to thr defeat of Germany? In the context of what actually took place in the war, how was the P-51 not? What made the P-38 or P-47 more crucial? How was the Spitfire, Hurricane or Yak more crucial?
I
That said like it or not the P51 is the aircraft that was used and it was the P51 that ensured the USA bombing was a success. For this alone the P51 deserves its place in the top 10
Logic.
All this fighting, all this fighting ... you see ... that's why the P-51 is NOT my favorite WW2 fighter .... people always get into fights about how good it is! Give me Mr. Fat Reliable from Republic with air con and a cigar lighter in the dash. Built for comfort ....
MM
Were they going to make nukes magically appear? You can only drop the number you have.
What logic is there to say the Germans would have multiple bombs dropped simultaneously on them. I don't see logic, I see more what if speculation.
If Germany was to be nuked in order to make it surrender, there would have to be no mercy. The US would have to wait until gather a good number of nukes. I wrote earlier that the cost benefit of such attacks would have to be considerated, however.
The P-47N was a great airplane that at +30,000 was much better than a P-51 (any model), but by the time that was realized there were countless P-51's and the war was seemingly headed toward an end.
The N had Slightly better performance than the P-51B-15 @75" WEP with racks and full internal load at 30,000 feet and slightly inferior performance (climb, speed, turn) to the P-51H with racks, full internal load @90" WI WEP at 30,000 feet but the 51H outclimbed it out ran it and out turned it from SL all the way up to 29,000 feet.
If there were such a thing as Allies 46' (like the Luft 46) things would have been different for the P-51 in that environment. Yet it was not that the P-51 was ever massively better than any other plane of its era but how quickly and effectively the Allies could match ratios of 10-1 or more Mustangs against the Germans on a consistent and ongoing basis.