Best Fleet Air Arm (Royal Navy) Aircraft of WW2 (1 Viewer)

Ad: This forum contains affiliate links to products on Amazon and eBay. More information in Terms and rules

We are making the statement that the discussion on the pros and cons of 37mm armament was nice, short, and simple.
 
Still kinda liked the P-39, they're becoming quite a restoration item these days...maybe someone will put that turbosupercharger in one and see just what we missed during the War...
 
I never really liked the P-39. Maybe the supercharger would have changed my opinion. But I thought it looked aweful (P-63 was better). And it's firepower wasn't very impressive (2 x .50cal and 4 x .30cal, and that nearly useless 37mm).
 
Even the 4 x .50cals of the P-63 were an improvement. 6 .50cals wouldn't have been bad and could have been done fairly easily.
 
Yes, the Mustang had that armament and that was pretty damn good. I still think a mix of cannon and machine gun is the best.
 
Yep, I agree with that...they did have success as a low-level attack aircraft, but I felt it was somewhat 'unfinished' as to it's real potential...would've been a bitch to get out of in a hurry with that door though....Anyway, I'm still rooting for the Seafire, with gulps of respect for the Swordfish...
 
My problem with the Seafire is that it really wasn't suited to carrier duty. It wasn't extremely rugged (not like a Hellcat or Corsair) and it's long nose and narrow undercarriage track didn't lend themselves to carrier landings.
 
Yes but the British are champions of carrier landings, come here Americans, let us show you how it's done.
 
Well established facts, yes, but warts and all, they still gave good sterling Offensive Defensive service - the FAA didn't get into the US aircraft until later, mostly ex-US Corsairs, as the Hellcats were much more easier to handle on carriers. They didn't have a long nose, so the Marine Corsairs flew off to airfields and continued from there...Seafires might not have been the bees-knees ON carriers, but off them they could scrap...they were afterall 'Spitfires in the Navy,' and their range wasn't the greatest, but that's how the Empire accomodated a shortfall, wasn't it ...? Incidentally, it was a British idea to create the angled-flightdeck, although they themselves took some convincing; - Abit like the Mosquito when still on the drawing-board; - until they saw it fly...then they were convinced....
 
This reply is slightly off topic.

We not only invented the Idea of the Aircraft Carrier, but we also invented all the items that are used on a modern Aircraft Carrier, the Steam Catapult, Arrester Gear, Gyroscopic Mirror Landing Sight, and as already stated the Angled Flight Deck, we also invented the concept of the Island Bridge, and when we announced that we were going to Scrap our Aircraft Carriers, one American Admiral is reputed to have said "who are we going to get our ideas from now"


 

Users who are viewing this thread