Groundhog Thread Part Deux - P-39 Fantasy and Fetish - The Never Ending Story (Mods take no responsibility for head against wall injuries sustained)

Ad: This forum contains affiliate links to products on Amazon and eBay. More information in Terms and rules

And why do you keep bringing up the P-39 when the first production was not until spring of 1941?
We can discuss the P-39 in general discussion without becoming overly obsessed with it.

Also, I hate to point out the obvious, but the Luftwaffe continued to attack England after October 1940.
The last major bombing offensive was Operation Steinbock between January and May 1944.
The last bombing of England was on 17 March 1945.
 
Are you saying the additional weight came from structural strengthening sometime after production of the C model in time for the D model and P-400? According to your P-39C manual empty weight was 5016lbs. The P-400 weighed 5550lbs empty. That's a difference of 534lbs. 240lbs was the self sealing fuel tanks. The book "Cobra" shows "minor empty and useful load changes" in Jan '41 and "engine and fixed equipment weight increase" in June '41 with production beginning in July, but those changes only account for 165lbs. I don't know where the additional 129lbs came from. Maybe it WAS structural bracing.
 
What were the 25 airframe modifications that grounded all P-39s delivered to UK and meant only 4 were ever in operational service?
 
Please give up on trying to educate me. I already have way more education than I can ever use. Thank you.

Your reply was to my post quoting Keith Park from post #2189. Do you honestly feel that a single seat fighter could bomb with any accuracy from those heights? Could they hit (or even come close to) a specific target?

And what is likely to happen to those Spitfires climbing from 20000' up to even 25000' where the fighter bombers were, not to mention the reported 30000' where their escort was? In the four minutes that they have to intercept don't you think that those planes or the escort above will see the Spitfires crawling up at less than 500fpm (vertical speed about 5.5mph, a little faster than walking). Aren't the escorts going to bounce the Spitfires from above? Seems like the ideal situation for the escorts, or even the FBs.

That seems crazy to me and I don't think the British were crazy. Not much interception going on there in my opinion. They weren't about to waste finite resources chasing fighter bombers at altitudes where any bombing accuracy at all was pure luck. Not then there are bomber formations at 20000' and under.
 
Please give up on trying to educate me. I already have way more education than I can ever use.
Yea - it shows
Your reply was to my post quoting Keith Park from post #2189. Do you honestly feel that a single seat fighter could bomb with any accuracy from those heights? Could they hit (or even come close to) a specific target?
I'll repeat because you're sooooo educated the brain cells might have had a hic-up...

"Even if one bomb landed on a laundromat in the middle of London, woke up a few hundred people, dispatched fireman and alerted air defenses, an objective was achieved."
 
Christ you really do talk some crap, if you drop bombs you hit things, I have already posted that two hospitals were hit and elsewhere 13 people were killed by a random bomb. Did you not read Parks instruction, the Spitfires on patrol were to shield the Hurricanes and Spitfires climbing behind.

You are incapable of reading absorbing or assimilating anything, thats why you never have no answer to anything but bang on day and night about the weight of am IFF transponder. Your post shows you havnt a clue, they were not on a cliff face or a ladder, they were in 3 dimensions, so time and separation are part of the discussion.

Now how about some answers to questions, not any more of your daft ill informed and considered opinions and doubts?
 
That's the problem, most bombs dropped from only 20000' by bombardiers flying medium bombers in formation didn't hit anything. Farmland, a lake, absolutely nothing of importance. You're taking one example of a bomb that happened to randomly hit a hospital when you have no idea what the bomber was actually aiming at. Formations of bombers had woeful hit rates and you think one fighter at 25000' will come anywhere near his target? Seriously?
 
You have already been posted the normal attack procedure for Jabo pilots this was obtained from pilots shot down by the RAF who did "take the bait". You consider you already have too much education, so you dont read anything at all, that is why talking to you is like arguing with pound of mince.

If you took the trouble to read the link I posted and compared it to the previously posted link to Park and Dowdings instructions you would have seen after Park introduced a system the losses inflicted on the LW climbed dramatically and RAF losses declined.
 
Last edited:

Users who are viewing this thread