Light fighters alternatives, 1935-1945 (11 Viewers)

Well, what is a "lightweight fighter?"

Everybody in this thread seems to have their own definition, which may explain why we have spent 17 pages largely talking past each other.. ;)

And why does somebody want a light fighter also seems like a pertinent question. I can come up with several answers:

  1. A country may for various reasons not have access to as high powered engines as their competitors, hence in order to remain competitive in performance they need to design a lighter aircraft. With various downsides in terms of range, weapons, armor, etc.
  2. Extending the life of previous generation aircraft in secondary roles, or selling them to other countries. Both existing aircraft, as well as production lines, maintenance procedures, are already existing etc. so this is an easy task compared to designing and fielding a new light aircraft from scratch. Good examples being the Wildcat/Martlet on escort carriers discussed earlier in the thread.
  3. Perhaps as a variation of the previous answer, if a nation is left behind in the arms race and cannot keep up, a fighter that started out as a normal weight fighter may very well, in terms of weight, be a light fighter towards the end of the war.
  4. Designing a new light aircraft as a cheaper easier/faster to build alternative to the current mainline aircraft.
  5. New technology and/or design approaches make it possible to make a lighter weight version of an existing aircraft, like the P-51H.
Depending on one's definition of "lightweight fighter", one could argue only option 4. above is a "proper" lightweight fighter. Option 1 is, well, a "normalweight" fighter given the technology available to the nation in question, even if some other nation might be able to make much heavier fighters with all the advantages that brings. Option 2, is not really something per se designed as a lightweight fighter, it's just keep using what's available. Same for 3. Option 4 is a proper lightweight fighter, but I'm hard pressed to find good examples of any such successful ones actually. And 5 is not really a lightweight fighter in the sense it would be a simpler cheaper aircraft than the mainline fighter, it just means that a technological improvement allowed mainline fighters to become slightly lighter.
 
Everybody in this thread seems to have their own definition, which may explain why we have spent 17 pages largely talking past each other.. ;)
Agree.
And why does somebody want a light fighter also seems like a pertinent question. I can come up with several answers:

  1. A country may for various reasons not have access to as high powered engines as their competitors, hence in order to remain competitive in performance they need to design a lighter aircraft. With various downsides in terms of range, weapons, armor, etc.
I can't recall this being done but perhaps I overlooked some aircraft. Very few nations, except very small ones made little or no progress in engine technology during the war.
Some made more progress than others to be sure.
Extending the life of previous generation aircraft in secondary roles, or selling them to other countries. Both existing aircraft, as well as production lines, maintenance procedures, are already existing etc. so this is an easy task compared to designing and fielding a new light aircraft from scratch. Good examples being the Wildcat/Martlet on escort carriers discussed earlier in the thread.
I have a lot of trouble accepting a 7900-8100lb clean fighter as "light weight" in any year. Sure, it was light compared to the F6F and F4U but the F4F/FMs were around 500lbs heavier than the La-5/7s and maybe around 100-200lbs lighter than a Ki 84, low performing they might be, light they were not. They were not cheap to make either. Yes, cheaper than larger American aircraft but they took a lot of aluminum and steel and labor compared to other people's 'standard' fighters.
Perhaps as a variation of the previous answer, if a nation is left behind in the arms race and cannot keep up, a fighter that started out as a normal weight fighter may very well, in terms of weight, be a light fighter towards the end of the war.
This does seem to be the case. My question is if continued production actually makes sense.
Case in point, Japan built around 5900 Ki-43s during WW II. However good they were in Dec 1941, all of 1942 and all of 1943, 3500 of them were built in 1944 and 1945. Somebody was not only slow on the draw, but their pistol was both screwed and glued in the holster.
Japan built 77% more Ki-43s in 1944 than they did in 1943. But by 1944 the Ki-43 was crap. Doesn't matter how good it was in 1942 or most of 1943. The Americans are not using P-39s/P-40s and F4Fs as their first line fighters anymore. Japan had two different 14 cylinder radial engines that would give about 25% more power at 6000 meters than the engine used in the Ki-43.
Designing a new light aircraft as a cheaper easier/faster to build alternative to the current mainline aircraft.
This does seem to be the common reason. Finding the proper balance was hard, cheap enough to increase production, good enough to at least hold it's own. This is where most (all?) light fighters failed. Italians tried with the S.A.I. 403 but we have no good data (service use) to know if it would have worked or not.
New technology and/or design approaches make it possible to make a lighter weight version of an existing aircraft, like the P-51H.
Yes the P-51H was lighter, maybe 600lbs lighter? or less? out of 7200-7300lbs light (no guns, etc). P-51H did perform better, a lot of performance gain was not due to just lighter weight.
 
A country may for various reasons not have access to as high powered engines as their competitors, hence in order to remain competitive in performance they need to design a lighter aircraft. With various downsides in terms of range, weapons, armor, etc.
Soviets were inn this ballpark, with their mass-produced M/VK-105 engine being behind the curve already in 1942.
Japanese were in the same category with the Sakae family powering almost all of the IJN fighters and a best part of IJA fighters (Ocass, basically), but they never opted to make a lightweight fighter, unile the Soviets.
Italians, French and Polish also fall here in the 1930s, plus a host of other countries that were not UK. Italians almost gotten the Ambrosini light fighters, but it dawned on them too late.

Perhaps as a variation of the previous answer, if a nation is left behind in the arms race and cannot keep up, a fighter that started out as a normal weight fighter may very well, in terms of weight, be a light fighter towards the end of the war.
My favorite example here is the Bf 109.

Designing a new light aircraft as a cheaper easier/faster to build alternative to the current mainline aircraft.
German 1-engined jet fighters come to the mind. So do many French designs during the panic days of 1939-40, as well as the Ambrosinis. Also the Finnish Mirsky, plus a lot of "~500 HP fighters" designs that either went stillborn, or were actually made and were not the good combat aircraft.
As you note, success was hard to find here.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back