Shortround6
Major General
Aircraft carriers were designed to be armored for the optimum range of the cruisers that presumably would be escorting the carrier.
Or running around on their own away from the main battle fleet.
While you are concentrating on the 30-40 enemy ships including BBs and CVs over.....................here, the sneaky enemy has snuck 8-12 ships (CA/Cl and DDs) around to...........................there anc caught you by surprise. Night/bad weather increased the chances of this scenario, ship mounted search radar decreased it.
While not factored in by the naval architects, command stupidity could negate armor protection.