'Turret-less' vs. 'turreted' tank-destroyers? (4 Viewers)

tomo pauk

Creator of Interesting Threads
15,882
5,823
Joined
Apr 3, 2008
Something like the Marder series, SU-76 and Achilles Avenger, vs. the American stuff.

A question: how much the lack of a rotating turret (or at least a wide-angle mount - say, 45-60 deg on the each side) for the main gun, was a problem for the 'European-style' destroyers?
 
Last edited:
The tradeoff was clear.
Set up in ambush configurations, they were shorter to begin with and easily hidden. Dug down into the earth a bit, the superior armor could deflect a return shot at the frontal armor.
 
The tradeoff was clear.
Set up in ambush configurations, they were shorter to begin with and easily hidden. Dug down into the earth a bit, the superior armor could deflect a return shot at the frontal armor.

I'm not sure who here plays what part - the 'Euro' stuff, or the American TDs?
 
Something like the Marder series, SU-76 and Achilles, vs. the American stuff.

A question: how much the lack of a rotating turret (or at least a wide-angle mount - say, 45-60 deg on the each side) for the main gun, was a problem for the 'European-style' destroyers?
"Achilles" was a turreted US M10 tank destroyer upgunned in 1944 to carry the British 17pdr AT gun.

I think you meant the 17pdr SP Valentine, "Archer" built on the Valentine tank chassis.

The idea for a British Army tank destroyer to carry the 17pdr AT gun first arose in Aug 1941 at the same time as that for a British designed tank armed with a 17pdr AT gun. While the tank was immediately pursued (It became the A30 Challenger in due course) the SP gun was shelved until mid-1942.

The basic problem with the 17pdr was its weight (about 3 tons with its carriage) and lack of manoeuverability on the battlefield. Initially a turreted but lower profile A30 was what was wanted but in Sept 1942 plans were changed to accept a limited traverse mount on a Cromwell (gun pointing forward) or Valentine (gun pointing backwards) chassis. It was the low profile element that was a key requirement. The latter won the development battle, even though it lacked the necessary speed, but by late 1943 was seen as a stopgap with the prospect of the "Achilles" arriving in 1944 filling part of the Army demand for such a vehicle, even though it had a profile higher than was considered desireable. In the end the order for 800 Archer was cut back to 665 with the end of WW2.

Meanwhile with the A30 Challenger tank reaching production in March 1944, attention could turn to a tank destroyer version that would meet all the War Dept requirements of cross country speed, protection and the all important low profile (helped by dropping the all round gun depression requirement and the second loader) From that came the 17pdr SP2 A30 "Avenger" with production beginning in Feb 1945. Ultimately only 80 of these were produced through to April 1946.
 
I'm not sure who here plays what part - the 'Euro' stuff, or the American TDs?
The shorter profile European style. Just the height difference was enough to make a huge difference.
 
The Hetzer was the most effective tank destroyer on the Eastern Front. Therefore, the answer is obvious: it wasn't a problem at all.
I disagree.

The StuG III proved to be the ultimate tank destroyer, in spite of it's original concept.

It holds, perhaps, the highest tank kills of any AFV of the war.
 
I'm not talking about anything contemporary I'm talking about world war II.

Serves me right for using the word that can have very different meanings.
Let me rephrase:
Would you be so kind to point me towards the tests, reports, experiences etc. made in time of ww2 or the immediate post-war time?
 
A number of years ago I ran across a US post-war analysis of the TD concepts. I think it is on DTIC so will have to wait until they are back up in order to check.

But, IIRC, the general consensus was that turreted TDs were better on the offense - unless it was not possible to carry a big enough gun to handle the expected opponents.

Turretless TDs were better on the defense, since they could be smaller and have significantly heavier armour on the front than a turreted TD of the same weight. They also could usually be more easily concealed, and - since they were acting defensively - they could be positioned such that the limited traverse of the gun did not come into play. The topcover afforded by the casemate types was noted as a necessity when facing air-burst artillery fire.

Again, IIRC, they commented on the Stug III & IV as an example of the turretless casemate types success in actual combat.
 
Last edited:
Serves me right for using the word that can have very different meanings.
Let me rephrase:
Would you be so kind to point me towards the tests, reports, experiences etc. made in time of ww2 or the immediate post-war time?
I got nothing.
 
The French studied multiple Allied and German tanks at Münsingen in 1945 which were of the models one would see in Normandy in 1944 here. The study was only from a firepower and gunnery standpoint.

They don't really conclude on whether a TD should or should not have a turret, only saying that casemated TDs cannot do all the missions given to regular tanks but are fine for close infantry support, delaying actions and defensive antitank missions. They said that the firing arc was adequate for these missions, and that their overall laying speed was acceptable.

Big caveat regarding M10: the Americans deliberately didn't give it powered traverse for doctrinal reasons unlike the later M18 and M36, so it didn't leverage the advantages of a turret as much as it should have.
 
the Germans divided their vehicles into two different categories, unfortunate for morale purposes the names used may not reflect actual usage.
Panzerjager was the original name for lightly protected chassis mounting an AT gun on top and often the crew was unprotected from rifle/mg fire from the rear and sides.
Jagdpanzer was the name for the more heavily armored/better protected vehicles with overhead protection.
Strangely while the MK IV version was called the Jagdpanzer IV the MK III version was still called a Stugg III even when employed in the same rolls.
Trying to actually hunt Soviet tanks with Marder IIs instead of letting the Soviet tanks come to the Marder IIs may not have gone well.
new04.jpg


A lot of these weapons were more properly described as self-propelled AT-guns but many armies wanted a more aggressive name.

there was also a significant difference in some of the "western" tank destroyers. The M-18 made a rather good name for itself but it could do things many other TDs could not do.
It was one of the fastest tracked vehicles in WWII so it could get into and out of positions very fast. It had power traverse that could rotate the turret 360 degrees in 24 seconds which means the gunner could get on target very quickly. The turret crew could also fire the gun quickly, at least while the ready ammo was available.
The US M-10 was slower, it was a bigger target. the turret was turned by hand cranks, and the larger ammo (but not more powerful) was harder/slower to load.
Many German Stug commanders racked up high scores with a combination of things. Experience helped a lot. A good commander could coach/instruct his driver to turn the vehicle quickly to line up the gun in the covered arc without hunting back and forth. This was sometimes quicker than the MK IV or Panther could turn their turrets. But it could not be done with inexperienced commanders and/or drivers.
British Archer was screwed. the driver faced the other way from the gun and he could not be in the driver's seat when the gun went off, unless he was very, very short.
Granted the 17pdr was powerful and when it came time to retreat the gunner could take his seat and drive away facing the retreat without needing help from the commander or trying to turn the vehicle 180 degrees after a short reverse drive.
The Challanger was rarely (?) employed as a "tank destroyer". It was most often (always?) mixed into standard tank formations at a rate of 1 or 2 vehicles per troop/platoon in the Cromwell units.
Granted the Germans often resorted to mixed units in some of their darker days but then tactics/doctrine really took a back seat.
 
They don't really conclude on whether a TD should or should not have a turret, only saying that casemated TDs cannot do all the missions given to regular tanks but are fine for close infantry support, delaying actions and defensive antitank missions. They said that the firing arc was adequate for these missions, and that their overall laying speed was acceptable.
Just about all TDs did not have co-ax machine gun for the main gun and only few had a hull mounted machine gun which did limit them for some missions, including infantry support. Granted there are host of photos showing American TD crews firing their 50cal guns from the top of the turret and they may have been supporting infantry but since the main gun is usually pointed somewhere else (sometimes over 90 degrees) and since the machine gunner has over 1/2 his body exposed it might not be close support.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back