Hello Amsel
Quote:
Originally Posted by hartmann
This ship isn't my favourite (I prefer the "Tirpitz" to the "Bismarck", and as powerful, I only can go for the "Yamato").
I never have claimed such thing.
By the way, It isn't the pure garbage which a lot of people tends to think. It was a very good designed ship.
I am sorry if I came across wrong.
No shame. Don't worry by that.
I enjoy speaking about ships.
I highly respect your knowledge
A lot of Thanks.

I am beginning to think though that the Littorio had some of the best armor of the Axis naval forces though.
I have seen works of this ship and a report made by British authorities after these ships were interned and all tends to indicate that those three ships Littorio, Vittorio Veneto and Roma, were built with very tight control systems, something strange in Italy, were the finishing of the manufactured products could be in this era very irregular, I think that this control was made by the own chief designer of the ships, Umberto Pugliese, which tended to visit frequently the docks were they were being built.
Regarding to armour, those ships had a very good quality steel plates, both the Vickers Terni cemented plates (very similar to the British Vickers cemented), and the homogeneous rolled steel plates, (AOD), a Chromium- Vanadium-Molybdenum steel, with some similarities to late German armour plates of tanks (not Navy, slightly different, which were Chromium-Molybdenum-Copper-Boron steel).
Also, the concept of armour scheme was spaced array, much like the German thinking.
They both countries played with decapping, yawing and fusing ideas (curiously, the US Navy also thought in this idea, but to fuse aerial bombs, the weather deck of 32-38 mm was put for this reason, but It was too little for heavy or very heavy shells), instead of put very thick plates and after them nothing. It was just another different point of view, different from the common wisdom of "AoN" schemes.
What is your take on that?
I highly consider these ships. The main problem which I find in them is the bad rough sea qualities and stability. They were very good ships in the Mediterranean (generally a very calm sea).
But If They had been operating in the Atlantic Ocean, or in the Arctic sea, they probably would have been troubles, especially if they took high water by damage. They had a very little metacentric height (but they had a big buoyancy reserve, so it was half compensated). But this is my honest opinion.
Hello Hartmann
my point was that Kirishima made only one hit and even if it have used AP shells, that would not have changed that.
Quote: "But If you take in account that the Us Naval report damage states that an AP shell of the heavy cruisers (just only 203 mm) punched trough the hull plate, trough 32 mm of STS steel over the main belt and finally another 207 mm of main belt and finished stuck here, you can see that If It would have been a AP shell of the Kirishima, It would have gone trough the entire belt and finished in the vitals."
I know that but because 8" gun of IJN had clearly higher MV than the 14" gun of Kongo class I'm not so sure on the ability of 14" AP shell to pierce the belt of SD at that range. Possibly but anyway Kirishima didn't hit the belt of SD.
Hello Juha
The MV was not very high (It was 775m/s) but they weight a lot more (some 673, 5 Kg according to Campbell book and to the US Navy records), and considering the range of the engagement (some 7000-8000 metres), I personally think that it was more than capable.
We have to consider that the guns of the KGV class had less MV (732 m/s) and that it was capable of punch trough 396 mm of cemented plate at 10000 yards. It was heavier, but it had less MV.
Also, if we take in account the 16 Inches L45 guns of the "NC", we see that in a brand new gun, the MV was of only 701 m/s (average gun, with eroded barrel, some 650-680m/s).
At 10000 metres, the "Kirishima " AP shell, carrying a velocity of 576 m/s it was enough to punch trough a plate of more than its calibre (356 mm) so, it could defeat the main belt. May be not the barbettes, but I think that It could do trough the belt. This was my point.
A lot of thanks and best regards
