I voted for LITTORIO but perhaps I may explain why NORTH CAROLINA is not a likely candidate in 1941.
At first You will notice that NORTH CAROLINA was a brand new ship (as was BISMARCK) and suffered from problems in her skeg and initial propeller design. She was prone to very heavy vibrations near her top speed of 27 kts which reduced her operational speed to under 26 kts or her sensible FC equipment was rendered useless. This means that she is a lot slower than other ships in the comparison. A modified propeller was not installed before 1942.
The details of her protection are not particularely great (altough not poor either). Her side protection system is made from inferior grade materials (US class A face hardened armour is not much better than japanese Vickers cementated, and according to Nathan Okun substantially weaker than Krupp KCn/a, british CA or Terni CA. The 15 degrees inclined 12 in main belt offers effectively no more protection than to those offered by the british HOOD and rates among the worst side protection system of all in comparison. Her deck protection systems is one of the better ones, however. Also her exposed vitals are at best protected average taken into account that 16in barbettes US class A are not any better than 14.2in Krupp KC barbettes with regard to stopping power.
Her AAA of the early 1941 period is worser than average with regard to layout, mk44 firecontroll and performances like ceiling and effective range. Her light AA outfit consisted of four jam prone 28mm quad mounts and ten .50cal twin Browning guns and looks paltry in comparison with some european BB´s of this time. The mk44 consisted spotting glasses but in no means a device to compute lead angles necessary for an efficient AAA battery- Remember, in this timeframe we also don´t have any VT-fuzes for 5in guns, those fuzes, 40mm Bofors batteries and the Mk51computing FC turned the system from a mediocre one into a great one!
While the 5in guns are acceptable AAA guns, they are in the meantime among the worst batteries for anti surface engagements with a comparably short range, long time of flight figures, soft capped common projectiles with significantly less punch than the 6in guns carried by other ships in this role. The 5in/38 biggest asset is the high volume of fire.
There is nothing wrong on her main guns

Altough she did not carried a gunlaying Radar in May 1941! All she had was FA (not installed in May1941), which was a very crude gunnery radar. The operator was required to swing the antenna back and forth manually while watching the oscilloscope, during which time he estimated the range. The radar performed satisfactorily when operating at peak performance, but this performance was difficult to maintain because of the relatively short life (about 75 hours) of the oscillator tubes. Detection range for large ships at ideal conditions was 14mls. It was not particularely exact in range and bearing discrimination and the fall of shots couldn´t be judged on display.
Also the operator had to call his ranges down into the FC-room where his information were feed into a computer by another operator. Her original radarset was more thought of as an support for the optical RF equipment.
By may 1941, NORTH CAROLINA still had a way to go until full fighting efficiency was achieved by all those minor and major modifications to take effect.