drgondog
Major
chuck, I don't have anything to add about P38 v P51 but I was glad to hear you mention your brother's comments about ACM at 20000 ft. I believe many of us on this forum wrongly put too much emphasis on high altitude combat and capabilities. I would bet that only a tiny minority of ACM took place above 25000 feet and most was well below that.
ACM at 20-30,000 was largely important only for 8th and 12/15th AF bomber escort as that is where the 'targets were' (both the bombers and the German fighters).
In winter of 1944-1945 many of the missions, particularly in bad weather, were flown in the middle altitudes in the ETO.. There were a lot more combats at low to medium altitude in this period than before.