You know Arab oil figured into that. They just didn't figure it was the right time to tell the Arabs about it.
The first oil well to strike oil in Saudi Arabia was in 1938.
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Ad: This forum contains affiliate links to products on Amazon and eBay. More information in Terms and rules
You know Arab oil figured into that. They just didn't figure it was the right time to tell the Arabs about it.
thanks John, but I think we have a good bunch already.'Yes, John I can imagine that. For me it's much easier to be objective with ww1 than with ww2. We were just not involved in the first one'.
I admire your staightforward honesty Marcel.
I hope people have learnt a few things from this thread.
WW1 is a very emotive war and feelings run deep as you have probably gathered....
You should be a moderator mate.
First befriend. Then politically-stabilize. Then drill. It's called, "advance-planning."The first oil well to strike oil in Saudi Arabia was in 1938.
First befriend. Then politically-stabilize. Then drill. It's called, "advance-planning."
I think they knew. What do you think?20 years ?? Get real.
Actually Monty was a Monash fan, describing him as the greatest general of WW1.Sounds like Monty took a few pages from Plumer. (Not being a Monty fan, I'll just stop there before I start anything.)
First befriend. Then politically-stabilize. Then drill. It's called, "advance-planning."
True. But in this case it was the Australian press which was acting against Monash, not the British press. I suspect that Haig would have been able to have 'a few words' with the British press if he felt the need, but with the Australian press I'm far less certain he would have any influence.Just a point to make here, but through and even in the post Victorian age, high ranking Generals (and Admirals) wielded considerable power in political and social circles.
If they were made to look bad (whether fact or assumption), they had the ability to "pull a few strings" and create difficulties for the source of their displeasure.
This is the Industrial Age. Economics is at the center of this Great War. Oil is economics. They're pumping it out of Persia and going all over the world looking for it. Arabia is no Persia. They drill and build and refine and distribute from there, what will the nomadic tribes say? But that doesn't mean they didn't scout it. And if the oil companies knew it was there, so did the politicians.Oil was first found in the region in NW Persia (Iran) in 1908.
In 1923 a concession was signed by the local shiek for oil exploration, but investors were lacking.
When oil was struck in Bahrain in 1933, investors surfaced but drilling wasn't successful in Saudi Arabia till 1938.
So what did the powers that be know about oil in the Persian Gulf, and Saudi Arabia in the WW1 era ? Nothing .
Then why was it a US company which exploited the oil, not British or French.This is the Industrial Age. Economics is at the center of this Great War. Oil is economics. They're pumping it out of Persia and going all over the world looking for it. Arabia is no Persia. They drill and build and refine and distribute from there, what will the nomadic tribes say? But that doesn't mean they didn't scout it. And if the oil companies knew it was there, so did the politicians.
Wait until there's a half-way stable regime to protect their big economic investment. In the meantime, befriend them. When they get it going, ring them up.
This is the Industrial Age. Economics is at the center of this Great War. Oil is economics. They're pumping it out of Persia and going all over the world looking for it. Arabia is no Persia. They drill and build and refine and distribute from there, what will the nomadic tribes say? But that doesn't mean they didn't scout it. And if the oil companies knew it was there, so did the politicians.
Wait until there's a half-way stable regime to protect their big economic investment. In the meantime, befriend them. When they get it going, ring them up.
Short answer. Because we struck the deal and you and the French struck out.Then why was it a US company which exploited the oil, not British or French.
Funny you should put it in those terms as it wasn't until the regimes formed that it became apparent to them water wasn't necessarily their most precious natural resource.It took them a long, long time to exploit it if they knew of it's existence in 1914-18.
Sorry, your theory just doesn't hold water, or oil.
Short answer. Because we struck the deal and you and the French struck out.
Funny you should put it in those terms as it wasn't until the regimes formed that it became apparent to them water wasn't necessarily their most precious natural resource.
Why are we discussing oil in the middle east in a "how ww1 started" thread?
I'll plead guilty to that. I was wondering how this critical economic resource figured into the British rounding up the Arabs to their cause.Why are we discussing oil in the middle east in a "how ww1 started" thread?