Light fighters alternatives, 1935-1945 (6 Viewers)

Well, what is a "lightweight fighter?"

Everybody in this thread seems to have their own definition, which may explain why we have spent 17 pages largely talking past each other.. ;)

And why does somebody want a light fighter also seems like a pertinent question. I can come up with several answers:

  1. A country may for various reasons not have access to as high powered engines as their competitors, hence in order to remain competitive in performance they need to design a lighter aircraft. With various downsides in terms of range, weapons, armor, etc.
  2. Extending the life of previous generation aircraft in secondary roles, or selling them to other countries. Both existing aircraft, as well as production lines, maintenance procedures, are already existing etc. so this is an easy task compared to designing and fielding a new light aircraft from scratch. Good examples being the Wildcat/Martlet on escort carriers discussed earlier in the thread.
  3. Perhaps as a variation of the previous answer, if a nation is left behind in the arms race and cannot keep up, a fighter that started out as a normal weight fighter may very well, in terms of weight, be a light fighter towards the end of the war.
  4. Designing a new light aircraft as a cheaper easier/faster to build alternative to the current mainline aircraft.
  5. New technology and/or design approaches make it possible to make a lighter weight version of an existing aircraft, like the P-51H.
Depending on one's definition of "lightweight fighter", one could argue only option 4. above is a "proper" lightweight fighter. Option 1 is, well, a "normalweight" fighter given the technology available to the nation in question, even if some other nation might be able to make much heavier fighters with all the advantages that brings. Option 2, is not really something per se designed as a lightweight fighter, it's just keep using what's available. Same for 3. Option 4 is a proper lightweight fighter, but I'm hard pressed to find good examples of any such successful ones actually. And 5 is not really a lightweight fighter in the sense it would be a simpler cheaper aircraft than the mainline fighter, it just means that a technological improvement allowed mainline fighters to become slightly lighter.
 
Everybody in this thread seems to have their own definition, which may explain why we have spent 17 pages largely talking past each other.. ;)
Agree.
And why does somebody want a light fighter also seems like a pertinent question. I can come up with several answers:

  1. A country may for various reasons not have access to as high powered engines as their competitors, hence in order to remain competitive in performance they need to design a lighter aircraft. With various downsides in terms of range, weapons, armor, etc.
I can't recall this being done but perhaps I overlooked some aircraft. Very few nations, except very small ones made little or no progress in engine technology during the war.
Some made more progress than others to be sure.
Extending the life of previous generation aircraft in secondary roles, or selling them to other countries. Both existing aircraft, as well as production lines, maintenance procedures, are already existing etc. so this is an easy task compared to designing and fielding a new light aircraft from scratch. Good examples being the Wildcat/Martlet on escort carriers discussed earlier in the thread.
I have a lot of trouble accepting a 7900-8100lb clean fighter as "light weight" in any year. Sure, it was light compared to the F6F and F4U but the F4F/FMs were around 500lbs heavier than the La-5/7s and maybe around 100-200lbs lighter than a Ki 84, low performing they might be, light they were not. They were not cheap to make either. Yes, cheaper than larger American aircraft but they took a lot of aluminum and steel and labor compared to other people's 'standard' fighters.
Perhaps as a variation of the previous answer, if a nation is left behind in the arms race and cannot keep up, a fighter that started out as a normal weight fighter may very well, in terms of weight, be a light fighter towards the end of the war.
This does seem to be the case. My question is if continued production actually makes sense.
Case in point, Japan built around 5900 Ki-43s during WW II. However good they were in Dec 1941, all of 1942 and all of 1943, 3500 of them were built in 1944 and 1945. Somebody was not only slow on the draw, but their pistol was both screwed and glued in the holster.
Japan built 77% more Ki-43s in 1944 than they did in 1943. But by 1944 the Ki-43 was crap. Doesn't matter how good it was in 1942 or most of 1943. The Americans are not using P-39s/P-40s and F4Fs as their first line fighters anymore. Japan had two different 14 cylinder radial engines that would give about 25% more power at 6000 meters than the engine used in the Ki-43.
Designing a new light aircraft as a cheaper easier/faster to build alternative to the current mainline aircraft.
This does seem to be the common reason. Finding the proper balance was hard, cheap enough to increase production, good enough to at least hold it's own. This is where most (all?) light fighters failed. Italians tried with the S.A.I. 403 but we have no good data (service use) to know if it would have worked or not.
New technology and/or design approaches make it possible to make a lighter weight version of an existing aircraft, like the P-51H.
Yes the P-51H was lighter, maybe 600lbs lighter? or less? out of 7200-7300lbs light (no guns, etc). P-51H did perform better, a lot of performance gain was not due to just lighter weight.
 
A country may for various reasons not have access to as high powered engines as their competitors, hence in order to remain competitive in performance they need to design a lighter aircraft. With various downsides in terms of range, weapons, armor, etc.
Soviets were inn this ballpark, with their mass-produced M/VK-105 engine being behind the curve already in 1942.
Japanese were in the same category with the Sakae family powering almost all of the IJN fighters and a best part of IJA fighters (Ocass, basically), but they never opted to make a lightweight fighter, unile the Soviets.
Italians, French and Polish also fall here in the 1930s, plus a host of other countries that were not UK. Italians almost gotten the Ambrosini light fighters, but it dawned on them too late.

Perhaps as a variation of the previous answer, if a nation is left behind in the arms race and cannot keep up, a fighter that started out as a normal weight fighter may very well, in terms of weight, be a light fighter towards the end of the war.
My favorite example here is the Bf 109.

Designing a new light aircraft as a cheaper easier/faster to build alternative to the current mainline aircraft.
German 1-engined jet fighters come to the mind. So do many French designs during the panic days of 1939-40, as well as the Ambrosinis. Also the Finnish Mirsky, plus a lot of "~500 HP fighters" designs that either went stillborn, or were actually made and were not the good combat aircraft.
As you note, success was hard to find here.
 
Too bad we don't have R-30 inflight ????

roussel30-1.jpg
 
The very first comment in this thread elaborates on the parameters of the "very light fighter" class. The list of aircraft at the beginning of this thread mostly has weights around 1,500 kg with one in the 2,500 class. And a few are made from wood. These are roughly in the 500 HP range. (The Martin-Baker MB2 probably shouldn't be on this list because of its size, horsepower, and weight.)

When we get into aircraft like the Zero or the P-51H, we are moving away from the keystone that holds everything together: cost. Cheap engines. Cheap airframes.
And why does somebody want a light fighter also seems like a pertinent question. I can come up with several answers:
Those are all great points.

Aside from the reasons you mentioned, there's a good case for parasite fighters as well as aircraft stored in caves.

I don't think the parasite fighter concept would ever have been feasible, except maybe from zeppelins. But if it were feasible, the lightest and smallest possible aircraft would be needed. In today's world, there are aircraft-launched aircraft, but these, AFAIK, aren't fighters but rather guided munitions.
 
I have a lot of trouble accepting a 7900-8100lb clean fighter as "light weight" in any year. Sure, it was light compared to the F6F and F4U but the F4F/FMs were around 500lbs heavier than the La-5/7s and maybe around 100-200lbs lighter than a Ki 84, low performing they might be, light they were not. They were not cheap to make either. Yes, cheaper than larger American aircraft but they took a lot of aluminum and steel and labor compared to other people's 'standard' fighters.

Yes, I meant the Wildcat being "light" in comparison to the next generation USN carrier fighters, not light in an absolute sense. But that was kind of my point, it was using an existing aircraft with existing production lines. Perhaps they could have stopped the rollout of escort carriers while waiting for bespoke light fighters and bombers were designed for them that would in some ways maybe have been "more optimal", but if that would have caused a delay in getting the escort carriers out there it would certainly have been much less optimal for the war effort as a whole.

This does seem to be the case. My question is if continued production actually makes sense.
Case in point, Japan built around 5900 Ki-43s during WW II. However good they were in Dec 1941, all of 1942 and all of 1943, 3500 of them were built in 1944 and 1945. Somebody was not only slow on the draw, but their pistol was both screwed and glued in the holster.
Japan built 77% more Ki-43s in 1944 than they did in 1943. But by 1944 the Ki-43 was crap. Doesn't matter how good it was in 1942 or most of 1943. The Americans are not using P-39s/P-40s and F4Fs as their first line fighters anymore. Japan had two different 14 cylinder radial engines that would give about 25% more power at 6000 meters than the engine used in the Ki-43.

Yes. Perhaps had they pushed the envelope slightly less with the Homare they would have been more successful in rolling out the Ki-84 as a replacement for the Ki-43? Considering late in the war they were seriously lacking in competent pilots and fuel, seems like fewer but more capable aircraft would have been very worthwhile for them.

In general, failure to successfully transition to next generation fighters seem to have been a big problem for the Axis as a whole. Ki-43, but also Bf 109, and A6M. I suppose by mid-war they were starting to be hard pressed by the Allies and they didn't have the breathing room to transition to next generation fighters.

This does seem to be the common reason. Finding the proper balance was hard, cheap enough to increase production, good enough to at least hold it's own. This is where most (all?) light fighters failed. Italians tried with the S.A.I. 403 but we have no good data (service use) to know if it would have worked or not.

I think a big problem with the concept of a light fighter (as in something explicitly designed to use a cheaper lower power engine, and save cost in other ways as well) in the time frame we're discussing is that aircraft technology was developing so incredibly quickly that if you started your fighter design with something less than the best engine available, by the point you actually have something flying and ready for service it was already hopelessly outclassed.
 
Japanese were in the same category with the Sakae family powering almost all of the IJN fighters and a best part of IJA fighters (Ocass, basically), but they never opted to make a lightweight fighter

Yes, even though the Ki-43 and A6M were light compared to many Allied fighters of the period, they were certainly mainline fighters in the sense of being designed to use the best engine they had at the time. Of course, as the war progressed they in some sense became lightweight fighters as the Japanese remained stuck with them while the US managed to transition to heavier next generation fighters.

My favorite example here is the Bf 109.

Indeed Germany failed to transition to next generation aircraft and the 109 remained one of their mainstays right until the final days to the war, similar to the Japanese with the Ki-43 and A6M.
 
A Spit V that has a 29 imp gal fuel bag behind the pilot will add another 29x5 = 145 miles of 'bring me home range', paying perhaps 250 lbs of extra weight penalty?
A light fighter done right will not be size of the Spitfire, either. With that, the weight can be also brough down.
You don't design a light weight fighter and expect it to do everything a regular fighter can do. You make sacrifices such that there are some useful missions the aircraft can carry out. Range is just about the first thing I would dump. I would not select a teeny tiny engine.

The Spitfire_XVIII, definitely not cheap, had a 33 imperial gallon tank in the rear fuselage. I am trying to figure out how this worked. The aircraft missed the war, so there was no desperate need to use the extra tank. The 75 US gallon tanks in the rear of P51D Mustangs affected made the plane more difficult to fly. On a Spitfire, the primary fuel tanks were located in the fuselage between the engine and pilot. This is an optimal layout for maintaining trim while using up fuel. On the Mustangs, the primary tanks were located in the wing roots, which is not as optimal for trip as the Spitfires'. The Mustang pilot sat further forward, where he got a better view over the nose. This permitted the 75 gallon tank to sit further forward compared to the Spitfire.

The Spitfire_XVIII I photographed recently, removed the 13 imperial gallon inboard wing leading edge tanks and the rear tanks, and added 22 imperial (?) gallon tanks in the wing leading edges outboard of the guns. I assume this is a safer layout than was used by actual combat Spitfires.
 
Yes, I meant the Wildcat being "light" in comparison to the next generation USN carrier fighters, not light in an absolute sense. But that was kind of my point, it was using an existing aircraft with existing production lines.
escort carriers, by nature, were 2nd string war ships. Their fighters were generally to stop/deter long range maritime recon aircraft, like Fw 200s or flying boats or float planes.
Didn't require first line fighters. But the allies did not put F4Fs against 1st line ground based air if they could help it. The Seafires at Salerno were put on board just 2-3 days before the invasion.
Yes. Perhaps had they pushed the envelope slightly less with the Homare they would have been more successful in rolling out the Ki-84 as a replacement for the Ki-43?
The Japanese (and Germans) wanted to make big leaps. Trouble is some of the leaps they made failed forcing retention of the old aircraft. They didn't have enough engineering capacity to both improve the existing aircraft and design new ones at the same time, so the existing ones only got minor make overs until it was too late. The Ki-61 should have been built in bigger numbers but problems with the V-12 engine never got sorted out and they never looked into a radial substitute until both bomb damage and an earthquake forced them to.
In general, failure to successfully transition to next generation fighters seem to have been a big problem for the Axis as a whole.
See above. Prof Willy and boys tried to change the 109 or replace it 3 times, 2 different 209s and the 309, none of them worked or they were too late.
I think a big problem with the concept of a light fighter (as in something explicitly designed to use a cheaper lower power engine, and save cost in other ways as well) in the time frame we're discussing is that aircraft technology was developing so incredibly quickly that if you started your fighter design with something less than the best engine available, by the point you actually have something flying and ready for service it was already hopelessly outclassed.
The S.A.I. 403 may be a case in point. Pretty good on paper in the summer/fall of 1943. In the Spring/summer of 1944 P-39s and P-40s were being replaced in existing squadrons by P-47s and P-51s. Better P-38s were showing up. British were sending newer Spits to Italy even if not the ones used in the invasion of France.
 
The Spitfire_XVIII, definitely not cheap, had a 33 imperial gallon tank in the rear fuselage. I am trying to figure out how this worked. The aircraft missed the war, so there was no desperate need to use the extra tank. The 75 US gallon tanks in the rear of P51D Mustangs affected made the plane more difficult to fly. On a Spitfire, the primary fuel tanks were located in the fuselage between the engine and pilot. This is an optimal layout for maintaining trim while using up fuel. On the Mustangs, the primary tanks were located in the wing roots, which is not as optimal for trip as the Spitfires'.
Spitfire_XVIIIs, according to an old source (could be wrong) had the two stage Griffon engine so CG and balance may be a bit off from even a two Stage Merlin. The fuselage and landing gear were beefed up according to one source and the wing was also beefed up for a greater gross weight. The Spit_XVIII did not see service in the war(?)
 
Yes, even though the Ki-43 and A6M were light compared to many Allied fighters of the period, they were certainly mainline fighters in the sense of being designed to use the best engine they had at the time.
Zero was designed around the least powerful 2-row engine they had, the company's Zuisei. Granted, it was quickly upgraded with the Sakae, that was offering another 100 HP. But there was also the Kinsei around, yet Hirokoshi opted not to use it when designed the Zero.


Of course, as the war progressed they in some sense became lightweight fighters as the Japanese remained stuck with them while the US managed to transition to heavier next generation fighters.
Very true.

You don't design a light weight fighter and expect it to do everything a regular fighter can do. You make sacrifices such that there are some useful missions the aircraft can carry out.
Agreed.
There is not much point of insisting the LW fighter carry some bombs around, nor that it has a very heavy firepower, like the 37mm cannons, or multiple 20mm.

Range is just about the first thing I would dump. I would not select a teeny tiny engine.

European fashion was the short range fighter anyway. Japanese will probably insist on good range, and sacrifice protection and/or firepower.
Agree on not using a teeny tiny engine, IOW the 2nd league engine is okay, but 3rd is not. Even in the late 1930s, I'd probably not be going under the Jumo 210 among the V12s, or the Mercury VIII (as used on Gladiators and Blenheim Is) among the radials; the radials will need more HP to achieve the similar speed figures. That is at least for the air forces that mattered for something in the day.

The Spitfire_XVIII, definitely not cheap,
Not sure that Griffon Spitfires might be categorized as the real light fighters of the day. Despite them being lighter than the Tempests or the heavy US stuff.
 
You don't design a light weight fighter and expect it to do everything a regular fighter can do. You make sacrifices such that there are some useful missions the aircraft can carry out. Range is just about the first thing I would dump. I would not select a teeny tiny engine.
yes, you select a mission or mission and try to design a fighter (or aircraft) to perform those missions.
What is the useful load needed to perform the mission/s?
What is the armament?
Crew is one or two?
How heavy is the radio?
What is the expected speed, altitude and range/endurance?
Once you have that you look for the engine that will provide the desired performance while carrying the military equipment and using the least fuel.
Trying to select an engine first and work backwards is rarely going to work.
Using the smallest engine to reach the desired speed and sacrificing altitude, range, communications and armament (firepower) is not going to end well.

British had 358.5lbs worth of "stuff" (including pilot) in a Spitfire IX not including guns, ammo, fuel and oil. This is going to be the same almost regardless of if you are building a 4000lb fighter or a 6000lb fighter or a 9000lb fighter.
Gun sight
signal cartridges
oxygen cylinders
first aid kit
W/T RT 1133
W/T....R 3002
Pilot/parachute/Dinghy

What are you going to leave out of the light fighter?

Once you know the load (and estimate fuel) you can look at the engine/s and then try to estimate the wing area needed to get the wing loading you want for take-off/landing and turning. The you can estimate weight of the airframe and then you can go back and refigure everything until you get an answer you like.

Prof Willy and boys would not have designed the 109 the way did if they had been told to use eight guns to begin with. Of course, an eight gun 109 using a Jumo 210 would have been a disaster.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back