in the most crucial role of the air superiority, the Spitfire was always superior.
That kind of depends on
where you need the air superiority?
A spitfire ix would outfly a p47c, a spit xiv would outfly a P47d-25,
a spit 21 would outfly p47N. Except in extreme altitudes
And at what ranges?
And not bad for an aircraft that first flew in March 1936, three years before Republic Aviation existed and when the best aircraft Seversky, its pre-1939 predecessor could design and launch was the P-35. I'd not want to take the latter up against any Mk of Spitfire.
The Spitfire was fast and it turned well. the 1930s version had a bit of a problem with climb.
BTW the
last P-35 was delivered before the 1st Spitfire squadron became operational.
The P-35A was not ordered by the USAAC, They were embargoed Swedish ordered aircraft and show up about 2 years late.
The YP-43 in limited production spanned the fall/winter of 1940/41 and production of the Spitfire II and V.
And we are back to range. The early P-35 was rated at 1050 miles. the P-35A was rated at 950 miles (?) and the YP-43 was rated at 800 miles.
Even if these were the "magic" levitate the plane to cruising altitude with full fuel ranges they still were going to out range the Spitfire.
First 70 something Spits had fixed pitch props and climbed like crap. P-35s had constant speed props which compensated for their low powered engines.
It would be nice were there to be an agreed definition of the 'greatest' 'best' etc words. For example one could choose some barely in service before the end of the war aeroplane just for performance or the Hawker Hurricane for winning the Battle of Britain which kept the Commonwealth in the war and was the base for all further events.
This is (and the rest of the post) is quite right. If we judge the "best" fighter as an air superiority fighter at a limited distance from it's own airfield then it is very hard to top the Spitfire.
Once we ask other things from it, like somewhat longer range, or ground attack things get a lot fuzzier.
P-47s wound up doing a lot things. And most of the time they just took standard P-47s of the time and hung stuff of the bottom and used them for whatever they were trying to do. No clipped wings, no extended wings, no low attitude engines, no high altitude engines. No extra armor packages.
Standard wing, standard engine (water injection added to existing ones, all production after a certain point had it). Same aircraft were doing everything, not saying the same squadrons did everything (different training/experience) but the same aircraft did.
Bombs, rockets and drop tank meant it could operate at a greater distance from the airfield in the ground attack role than the Spitfire.
Or carry a lot more "stuff" at the same distance. Does that make it "great"?
And from 1943 on very few planes could deal with a P-47 at over 30,000ft. Other planes got better but P-47s got better too.
P-47s used 3/4 different engine set ups.
Early P-47s
Early P-47s with water injection (and new props)
Later P-47s with new turbos, (and still with water injection)
Engines were pretty much the the same.
P-47M & N with new "C" series engines.
This "standardization" is one reason that they made so many P-47s. They improved them with dash numbers but they weren't swapping engines in and out or even changing guns (perhaps they should have?). They just made a crapload of them and sent overseas and let the squadrons get on with it.