... arguing about ... the use of an aeroplane that didn't enter scale production is just wishful telescoping.
In a fantasy scenario (no B-29) it's incorrect to assume everyone involved would follow the exact same course of action as happened in reality.
If we change the reality of the B-29 existing we have to change the reality of everyone's reaction to that fact.
The opportunity to completely avoid Operation Downfall would be up for grabs. I think it's reasonable to assume getting a few Lancaster VIs or (Lincoln Is) up to snuff would have received a bit more attention and resources than it did.
I also think it's unreasonable to set the maximum level of acceptable risk of this pivotal mission to that of what Enola Gay and Bock's Car experienced.
Last edited: