drgondog
Major
I didn't intentionally give you a dislike - I will look and change.
Just looked - no 'dislike' from me or anyone that I could see.
What War Movie Would You Show Your Son or Daughter?
- Thread starter NevadaK
- Start date
Ad: This forum contains affiliate links to products on Amazon and eBay. More information in Terms and rules
Just looked - no 'dislike' from me or anyone that I could see.
TheMadPenguin
Senior Airman
Sorry for the Senior Moment; it's Disagree not a Dislike.
Peter Gunn
Master Sergeant
I actually agree with you, the sound on the DVD was terrible, it seems the technicians in charge of that part of the transfer were out to lunch that day. My copy is almost un-listenable... if that's a word. Pity too because as drgondog says, it's a magnificent score.
Common problem with today's digital "remasters" of original analog recordings. Audio recorded in the early days of monaural vaccum tube "Hi-Fi" was mixed and reproduced for playback on machines with a much "rounder" sound and lacking the extreme audio bandwidth and dynamic range of today's solid state surround sound powerhouses.
Today's hotshot young digital audio engineers tend to listen to the "old stuff" and complain it lacks "punch" and "presence" and then set out to correct those deficiencies. The result tends to sound "jarring" and "discordant" to us geezers listening on anything less than studio grade equipment, or with consumer or "prosumer" class speakers or headsets. We don't WANT to hear every little harmonic and sub-harmonic and stage reverb we never heard in our youth.
I grew up listening to a particular performance of Tchaikovsky's 1812 Overture by Antal Dorati and the Philadelphia Philharmonic, complete with live recorded cannon fire and carillon bells, on my parents' 1955 monophonic, vaccum tube Magnavox "Hi-Fi". A couple weeks ago I heard the same recording "digitally remastered" on a neighbor's $5000 home theater system and thought it sucked. He had snagged it out of the bargain bin at Walmart and thought he'd made a great find. Rare for me, I kept my mouth shut.
Last edited:
TheMadPenguin
Senior Airman
"Rare for me, I kept my mouth shut. "
We may have similar afflictions...
We may have similar afflictions...
The curse of our generation.
"Stop, hey, what's that sound?
Everybody look what's goin' down!"
(The other meaning of B.S.)
GrauGeist
Generalfeldmarschall zur Luftschiff Abteilung
Ages ago (like, many decades), I installed car audio systems and to sound-check and/or adjust the equalizer-booster settings (and fader), I used classical music that was direct audio recorded, not digitally remastered or "enhanced" with Dolby.
Some of the works I used was Tocata and Fuge in D minor, movements from the Jupiter symphony and even parts of Die Valkure.
The guys would rib me, but if the system could handle such complex music, it could handle anything.
Some of the works I used was Tocata and Fuge in D minor, movements from the Jupiter symphony and even parts of Die Valkure.
The guys would rib me, but if the system could handle such complex music, it could handle anything.
drgondog
Major
My copy has a superb sound track....
TheMadPenguin
Senior Airman
So I repeat: What version do you have? I seek info by which I can get what you have. I'd love to have a copy with decent (or no) music.
drgondog
Major
DVD commercially sold 10-15 years ago. I would have to dig it out. When I have time I will.
A late answer
-BoB,
-The Way to the Stars, almost no aerial scenes but on the life at a RAF station, later given to the USAAF and nearby pub. It gives good picture how expensive the war was in human lives and how the war "ate" m3n.
-Angels One Five, saw it as a child, one of the reasons I began to be interesting in the history of aerial warfare. That was over half a century ago but I still remember a vic of Hurricanes and a smoking rear fuselage of a crashed Bf 110.
-Blue Max, WWI movie, if the son/daughter is mid teen or older, some sexy scenes. Also plenty of aerial combat
-Dark Blue World was not bad
-Dunkirk, also its air combat parts are good.
-BoB,
-The Way to the Stars, almost no aerial scenes but on the life at a RAF station, later given to the USAAF and nearby pub. It gives good picture how expensive the war was in human lives and how the war "ate" m3n.
-Angels One Five, saw it as a child, one of the reasons I began to be interesting in the history of aerial warfare. That was over half a century ago but I still remember a vic of Hurricanes and a smoking rear fuselage of a crashed Bf 110.
-Blue Max, WWI movie, if the son/daughter is mid teen or older, some sexy scenes. Also plenty of aerial combat
-Dark Blue World was not bad
-Dunkirk, also its air combat parts are good.
wingnuts
Airman 1st Class
Sean Connery was in the movie "The Longest Day" as Pvt Flanagan which came out in 1962, the same years as "Dr No".
Admiral Beez
Captain
'The Fallen', a little known, independently made film that is the most accurate depiction of the American experience of ground combat in the European theater to date that I have seen so far. Worth an 'Honorable Mention' is 'Memorial Day' (2012).
The HBO movie 'The Pacific' is unsuitable for younger viewers; in fact it is actually 'toned down' by the film makers as an accurate depiction was considered unsuitable for older viewers.
Last edited:
I looked that one up and it sounds excellent, but it's apparently not available anywhere in the US for (legal) viewing. I was ready to pay $$$ to watch it on Amazon or whatever because a good war movie is a rare pleasure. The plot of this one sounds superb. I guess I'll have to pursue some other clandestine method if I want to watch it which is a shame because I'd like to throw the filmmakers a bone...
The Fallen (2004) directed by Ari Taub. Available at Amazon DVD movies. Also available on ebay but those are from overseas sellers.
GrauGeist
Generalfeldmarschall zur Luftschiff Abteilung
GrauGeist
Generalfeldmarschall zur Luftschiff Abteilung
lol...just as I posted that, I realized you may have meant streaming!
