Hello Amstel.
From Nathan Okum
I have the results of the examination of German Krupp armor plants and
their own test plates made before and during WWII. The plants were still
using WWI-era equipment (no improvements at all, from what the Allied
examiners could see) and the results for German KC n/A plates in the 8-10"
range were VERY poor (20% variation in the ballistic limits from their own
tests), though the thinnest plates (rarely used) and the thickest plates
were of more narrow, acceptable variability (at least half of the Krupp KC
n/A plates made in th 8-10" thickness range would have failed outright any
U.S. ballistic testing calibrated for the average quality, while even a 2%
reduction of U.S. Class "A" plate quality in a production lot was of
considerable interest during wartime U.S. armor production (special
waivers had to be obtained to allow the plates to be used) -- Krupp
wouldn't have even noticed such a small drop in quality!).
It is completely contradictory with my documents from German, British and even US origin. I wouldn't take as gospel what Nathan Okun says.
All the German armour steel lots were checked and all had to pass a very strict (probably the most strict of any nation) ballistic and metallurgical number of tests, all the way.
Also, He doesn't cite the fact that the III barbette of the Battleship "Missouri" cracked caused only by mechanical stresses running at high speed. Also the other cracks which are present in other parts of the ship which were detected after this incident.
The sterns of several German WWII warships -- including BISMARCK --
literally breaking off under shock from a torpedo hit shows poor design
practice
The sterns of Bismarck and another KM ships were perfectly designed. He takes account of some misleading facts.


We should ask him If He knows about the multiple maritime disasters and quasy disasters of the merchant ships class "Liberty" thanks to poor design and badly executed weldings, or about the bad design of Bows in American cruisers, which tended to fail when struck by torpedoes, or even by only ocean waves, as the Heavy cruiser "Pittsburgh".
By the way. It's difficult to think this, when after the war all the German welding manuals and procedures captured were translated and used as a standard basis for the new metallurgical parameters in US manufacture.
Everyone has a favorite ship and the Bismarck is a great ship.
This ship isn't my favourite (I prefer the "Tirpitz" 8) to the "Bismarck", and as powerful, I only can go for the "Yamato").
But it was not the invincable ship that it was made out to be.
I never have claimed such thing.

By the way, It isn't the pure garbage which a lot of people tends to think. It was a very good designed ship.
Another factor is the amount of armor on the citadel, turrets and barbettes of the North Carolina. In WWII these areas are what took the majority of the hits. The North Carolina clearly outclasses the Bismarck
The "North Carolina" doesn't surpass the "Bismarck" class (compare the weight of armour steel used in both and the length of the armoured citadel of both also). The only thing were it was only slightly more protected was in the turrets, with 16 inches of homogeneous armour versus 14-14,50 inches of cemented armour.
The North Carolinas guns made the Bismarck vulnerable up to 26,000 though she had that deck slope behind the belt.
From the belt was almost invulnerable at any range, especially the more the range, the more difficult to penetrate It as It had this slope in the deck plus the air gap between them, which made It virtually impervious to all shell by decapping/yawing and fusing activation. Concerning decks, it was the same thing. The "Bismarck" first had a decapping deck of 50 mm to 80 mm and after that, some 5 metres below (air gap), the "Panzerdeck", which were another 100 mm of steel. The North Carolina had only an armoured deck of only 90 to 105 mm mm (3,6 to 4,1 Inches). Take also a "weather deck" of 32 mm, but not very spaced between them (just only a couple of metres).
Also, the guns of the "Bismarck" were very capable of defeat all the vertical armour of the ship, and also the horizontal armour.
All tends to indicate that both were capable of sink mutually (depending of the first shot).
Bismarck's decks were vulnerable past about 20-21,000
No. It hadn't enough obliquity to punch trough both armoured decks and air gap.
it was also possible for North Carolinas guns to punch through the upper belt thern still penetrate the MAD from around 16,000 out.
It would be an extremely lucky shot.
It is decapped by the upper belt (145 mm of cemented steel), which suppose the elimination of some 150 Kg of the shell (all the piercing cap). It could be damage or not the fuse, but It was also yawed (some 15% of kinetic energy less. To reach the MAD, It would have to be rejected in almost perpendicular direction to the impact in the belt.
So I wouldn't say impossible, but very improbable.
] Hello Hartmann
A couple short notices
Only one of the hits on South Dakota on 15 Nov 42 was 14". So I doubt very much that SD would have sunk if Kirishima have had proper AP shells.
Hello Juha
Yes, I know it. A common high capacity HE shell type 0.
But If you take in account that the Us Naval report damage states that an AP shell of the heavy cruisers (just only 203 mm) punched trough the hull plate, trough 32 mm of STS steel over the main belt and finally another 207 mm of main belt and finished stuck here, you can see that If It would have been a AP shell of the Kirishima, It would have gone trough the entire belt and finished in the vitals.
If you read Norman Friedmann book, in the page 279:
"Her unlucky companion, the "Souht Dakota", achieved little except to demonstrate that even modern battleships could be severely damaged at short range by cruiser and destroyer fire".
The belt of North Caroline was inclined , see Amsel's message #192 , the picture is from a good book, I can give you the title, if you want.
Yes, it is true. It is inclined some 15º.

I confused ship armour schemes (I vaguely remembered the KGV armour scheme and mixed It with the "NC"). Sorry by this.
I have this book also. Pretty good.
Quote:
Originally Posted by hartmann
There were only two times where American BBs engaged another enemy BB:
I think you misread my post. I stated the USN after Pearl Harbor never lost another BB for ANY reason, not just from BB/BC encounters.
Ok. I understand now what you liked to say.
The US was the only major power that could state this - with the exception of Russia due to the lack of BB/BC's
Soviet Union had 3 old battleships, and one of them was sunk by bomb attack (the battleship "Marat") in Kronstadt.
I echo Juha by saying that South Dakota would probably have not been sunk if Kirishima had been using AP ammo. Modern BBs were all extremely difficult to sink with shellfire and South Dakota was no exception.
Well, that is not so difficult.
You only have to shell the ends of the ship even with low calibre shells and make water flow to the ship. Then it comes at a point were the metacentric stability is not enough to compensate the roll produced by waves and It will capsize, even with relativelly low damage to the vitals. In this matter it must be considered the buoyancy and not to have excessive topweigh, among with a high metacentric height (it will remain afloat more time).
I hope It can help something. Best regards
