A Chinese Spy Balloon?

Shoot it down?

  • Yes, Fighter

    Votes: 7 77.8%
  • Yes, ADA

    Votes: 1 11.1%
  • No

    Votes: 1 11.1%

  • Total voters
    9

Ad: This forum contains affiliate links to products on Amazon and eBay. More information in Terms and rules

The problem the Air Force faced, was several, actually.

First, shooting down the balloon meant that the array, which was the equivellent of three school busses, would be tumbling out of control for about 11 miles to earth with no predictable point of impact.

Next, trying to shoot a missile at the balloon, which has next to no RCS, would be complicated, most likely the missile(s) would pass through and continue on until falling to earth - again, with no idea of where the missile(s) would end up.

Last, trying to make a gun run with 20mm cannon would be difficult, too, since the balloon would offer no resistance to the shells and now you have a rain of 20mm cannon shells falling to earth while the balloon (which is of substantial size) slowly deflates. It could take days for enough helium to vent enough to bring it to earth.

I don't know if they considered hitting it with flares, which would be tricky enough, but would certainly damage the balloon's material enough to bring it down much faster than cannon rounds.

So they waited until it had passed out to sea before taking it down. Missiles would make the biggest holes and they'll fall into the ocean without putting people at risk.
The balloon's payload has enough RCS to be seen.
 
The problem the Air Force faced, was several, actually.

First, shooting down the balloon meant that the array, which was the equivellent of three school busses, would be tumbling out of control for about 11 miles to earth with no predictable point of impact.

Next, trying to shoot a missile at the balloon, which has next to no RCS, would be complicated, most likely the missile(s) would pass through and continue on until falling to earth - again, with no idea of where the missile(s) would end up.

Last, trying to make a gun run with 20mm cannon would be difficult, too, since the balloon would offer no resistance to the shells and now you have a rain of 20mm cannon shells falling to earth while the balloon (which is of substantial size) slowly deflates. It could take days for enough helium to vent enough to bring it to earth.

I don't know if they considered hitting it with flares, which would be tricky enough, but would certainly damage the balloon's material enough to bring it down much faster than cannon rounds.

So they waited until it had passed out to sea before taking it down. Missiles would make the biggest holes and they'll fall into the ocean without putting people at risk.

Apparently the order was given on Wednesday to shoot it down, however, the Pentagon advised against it until it was over the Eastern coast.
 
Will the crew chief of the F16 that fired the missile that took down the balloon, be authorized to paint a balloon kill on the jet? LOL

It was an F-22 that fired the shot.

And this photo is not real, but here you go…

01E8EB43-909B-4731-B5DC-67D365C20671.jpeg
 
Any conjectures on just what intelligence they were trying to collect? It's so much easier to collect signals from an innocuous semi truck hauling a trailer full of gear. Optical imagery? Buy it from commercial sources. Missile silo coordinates? Bribe the Russians for it. They'll be happy to sell that info.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back