And that is a major difference.
A lot depends on who is responsible for what.
What was the Imperial Japanese Navy
responsible for?
If it was responsible for naval bases in areas that the Army was not responsible for then having a fast climbing interceptor to defend the bases might have been very important.
The British in 1938-40 was thinking about a different airplane for base defense than for carrier use, so the Japanese were not alone in this thinking.
In the US the areas of responsibility were a bit different. The Army had a greater share of the responsibility of naval base defense.
Navy planes were not going to sit on airbases while they were being attacked but it was the armies job to supply the needed interceptors or at least the bulk of them. .
In the Pacific things got a little mixed up and the Marines did supply land based squadrons but that was after Pearl Harbor.
If the Navy was responsible for air defense of some of the Island bases with no Army air units within support range the answers become different.
The thought process for the Raiden started in 1938 with the written specification showing up in Sept 1939. Work on the A6M slowed down work so the first prototype didn't fly until March of 1942 but the initial specification (request) called for a speed of 600kph at 6,000 meters, a climb of 5 1/2 minutes to 6,000 meters, a landing speed of 130 kph and a take-off run of 300 meters in zero wind. Some of these are in conflict with each other, especially in 1939-41 with existing or promised engines.
A carrier fighters needs a bigger wing for lower landing speed and shorter take-off run. A bigger wing means lower top speed and less climb.
The J2M1 prototypes used 1430hp engines for take-off. They were over 1000lbs heavier than an early A6M.
Something (or several somethings) had to go.
View attachment 690706
Early prototype with small sloped windscreen and the the long extension shaft for the prop.
Trying to land this thing on a carrier would have been suicidal. But a larger wing, short nosed, tall windscreen fighter wasn't going to come close to the desired speed.