I agree with you. Just trying to point out the limitations of "light" fighters.
It comes down to, quite literally, what do we want to leave out?
The R-1830 is not much lighter than the V-1710 once you figure in the radiator/coolant.
To shift to an Allison powered "light fighter" study and using figures from P-40N-25 just for the engine we are looking at
335lbs..................engine section (mount and cowling)
1340lbs...............engine
92lbs....................engine accessories (pumps, generator, etc)
29lbs....................engine controls
417lbs.................propeller
45lbs....................starter/s
235lbs..................cooling system (and this is the aluminum radiator)
92lbs....................oil system
2585lbs...............not including fuel system (fuel tanks)
maybe a few lbs can be shaved off but we only have 3415lbs left for a 6000lb light fighter????
except
37lbs.................instruments
97lbs.................surface controls
150lbs..............hydraulics
203lbs..............electrical
297lbs..............armament prov (includes the armor and B/P glass, around 90-100lbs?)
59lbs.................furnishings (seat, etc)
223-130lbs......Communications (P-40N had by far the largest allowance, most P-40s were closer to the 130lb figure)
973lbs sub total
3558lbs without airframe, armament, fuel or fuel tanks or pilot.
And we only have 2442lbs left for all that "stuff" if we want a 6000lb limit.
maybe we can shave some control linkage, hydraulics and electrical and if we use only 4 guns instead of 6 we can get rid of some of the brackets and ammo boxes.
314lbs.......................four .50 cal gun installation
240lbs.......................800rounds .50 cal ammo.
600lbs.......................100 US gallons of fuel
60lbs..........................oil
180lbs........................pilot
1394lbs......................disposable load
leaves 1048lbs for the airframe and landing gear.
The Yak-3 is carrying about 120lbs less gun and about 80lbs less ammo. American .50s are heavy.
Yak-3 uses pneumatic systems for flaps, landing gear and brakes. Lighter than electric or hydraulic.
Yak-3 held about 100 US gallons of fuel. Weight of tanks and protection???
If the Allison "lite" gets down to around 6000lbs maybe we can make the landing gear only 2/3rds as heavy as P-40?
Basically, I do not see any way for the Americans to build a 6000lb fighter without changing a bunch of things from the American standard way of doing things. I mean standard American accessories, either electric or hydraulic. Going below a standard US radio set (which got heavier and more capable as the war went on), Using a non-standard US propeller.
Standard G loading limit/standards and so on.
The P-40N had an 1130lb wing, yes we can cut it but we have to cut it enough to make the fuselage, tail and landing gear out of the saved weight.
