Trailer for "The Mighty Eighth"
- Thread starter Thorlifter
- Start date
Ad: This forum contains affiliate links to products on Amazon and eBay. More information in Terms and rules
Airframes
Benevolens Magister
Sorry - that CGI looked utter rubbish, more like a cartoon comic book.
Lucky13
Forum Mascot
Sorry, have to agree with Terry here...looked more like something for a computer game.
GrauGeist
Generalfeldmarschall zur Luftschiff Abteilung
This is like the 4th thread about the "mighty eighth" CGI flick 
Lucky13
Forum Mascot
......and it still haven't improved, no?
Made me think of those Sci-fi movies from the 50's by whatshisname....Ed Wood!
Made me think of those Sci-fi movies from the 50's by whatshisname....Ed Wood!
bobbysocks
Chief Master Sergeant
i can overlook hokie cgi if the flick has a decent storyline and the acting is above average. i may not pay to see it but will watch it at some point. i give cgi a little leeway hoping they get it right in the year to come.....i grew up watching movies with worse visual effects....rockets that flew and you could see the wires....trailing smoke that floated upwards. so anything is an improvement...lol
rogerwilko
Airman 1st Class
- 102
- Mar 5, 2009
I agree. The visual affects old old were a laugh!
Like the scene in the late 60's version of Midway.
Charlton Heston in a carrier approach in a badly damaged SBD Dauntless, Then it shows a SB2C Helldiver rounding out below the ramp, and trying to climb up to it. Then it's cuts to a mid 50's Navy jet doing crash and burn on the ramp.
I'm sure the producers at the time thought 9 out of 10 people would never know the difference, modern producers aren't any worse.
It's just that they now have the technology to bring out something accurate, and realistic, but they're too lazy to take the time to get the details right.
Charlton Heston in a carrier approach in a badly damaged SBD Dauntless, Then it shows a SB2C Helldiver rounding out below the ramp, and trying to climb up to it. Then it's cuts to a mid 50's Navy jet doing crash and burn on the ramp.
I'm sure the producers at the time thought 9 out of 10 people would never know the difference, modern producers aren't any worse.
It's just that they now have the technology to bring out something accurate, and realistic, but they're too lazy to take the time to get the details right.
- Thread starter
- #9
Thorlifter
Captain
You know, maybe it's not perfect, but I'll take just about any airplane movie right now (other than Red Tails). And with Hanks and Spielberg you know it will be at least pretty good. I'm hopeful they will tighten up the CGI.
GrauGeist
Generalfeldmarschall zur Luftschiff Abteilung
Well, the movie "Flyboys" was entertaining: if one ignored all the red DR.Is and the incredible aerobatics that defied physics...and the half-hearted storyline...and the...wait, nevermind.
By the way, the producer of Flyboys said he wanted the dreideckers all red so the audience knew who the Germans were...
When I heard that during the interview (I was eating dinner at the time), I almost blew my dinner all over the coffee table.
By the way, the producer of Flyboys said he wanted the dreideckers all red so the audience knew who the Germans were...
When I heard that during the interview (I was eating dinner at the time), I almost blew my dinner all over the coffee table.
I believe this is not the Hanks/Spielberg production. As I understand it, this is some kind of "example footage" for some other project, which may or may not get produced.
It states 65 planes???? I think in the shoot it looks like 200+? That's why 12 O'clock High will always be one of if not my favorite B17 movie real BIRDS in that movie.But to be honest the old Hasbro B-17 game has better graphics than that clip and that Hasbro game is from 1998!
Lucky13
Forum Mascot
.....and as with any other 90+/120 minutes war movie, it'll be 15/20 minutes (if we're lucky) of action and the rest lovey dovey.....uuuggh!
RebelRunner
Recruit
Doesn't look half bad, actually. I have my doubts about the "B-17 sandwich", but I'm setting my outlook to Cautiously Optimistic.
GrauGeist
Generalfeldmarschall zur Luftschiff Abteilung
It actually happened.
More info about that event in the other Mighty Eighth thread: http://www.ww2aircraft.net/forum/wwii-videos/mighty-eight-teaser-footage-39121.html#post1075261
Definite video game feel. Something I can overlook if the story is good and they don't get ridiculous.
That's my biggest beef with CGI. Not the game-like image quality, but the stupid action/stunts they put in films nowadays. It used to be, a stunt-man/stunt-driver/actor, actually had to perform the action seen. Not any more. While action films have always been ridiculous, they're now just plain absurd.
That said, CGI could be a great tool for aviation flicks, allowing the production to detail events that never could have been reenacted otherwise.
That's my biggest beef with CGI. Not the game-like image quality, but the stupid action/stunts they put in films nowadays. It used to be, a stunt-man/stunt-driver/actor, actually had to perform the action seen. Not any more. While action films have always been ridiculous, they're now just plain absurd.
That said, CGI could be a great tool for aviation flicks, allowing the production to detail events that never could have been reenacted otherwise.
Last edited:
vikingBerserker
Lieutenant General
Man, I agree with that!
Lucky13
Forum Mascot
Likewise!
Users who are viewing this thread
Similar threads
