A look at German fighter Ace kill claims (2 Viewers)

[Thumpalumpacus]

I must have misunderstood. That's my fault sorry about that.

No need to apologize, brotha. We need not agree on every.single.thing in order to learn from each other, and on my part, I've learnt a lot from you and others here too. I too may have misread how vociferous you were (or weren't) about the supremacy of records being infallible.

In either event, it's just a discussion, and in one where my knowledge is so limited, I shoot questions and the occasional opinion, which is all I've done.

 

[CHen10]

I think the book that started all this has an agenda, and that agenda includes discrediting Hartmann. I think that largely from reading this thread. If it doesn't have that agenda, then this thread is NOT a good advertisement for the book. The agenda may or may not be accurate but, if not, it sure seems that way to me.

Verified Victories isn't the first book to ever discuss overclaiming. There are loads of books which discuss overclaiming.

Verified Victories has no agenda. It's unfair to say a book has an agenda when you haven't even read it

 

[CHen10]

No need to apologize, brotha. We need not agree on every,single.thing in order to learn from each other, and on my part, I've learnt a lt from you and others here too. I too may have misread how vociferous you were (or weren't) about the supremacy of records being infallible.

In either event, it's just a discussion, and in one where my knowledge is so limited, I shoot questions and the occasional opinion, which is all I've done.

Yeah it's not a big deal.