Aircraft Disasters

Ad: This forum contains affiliate links to products on Amazon and eBay. More information in Terms and rules

There are several channels on YouTube devoted to MS Flight Simulator re-enactments of air crashes. While not always 100% technically accurate, they can give you the general narrative of these accidents as well as the final investigation results and some speculations on circumstances. Most of them are done from the perspective of "armchair experts" who've clearly never actually flown other than as an airline passenger.
Cheers,
Wes

Hi.

Thank you.
I'll check them.
 
I've been through a Navy chamber ride which featured "mask off" stops at 26K, 32K, and a pressure breathing exercise at 46K.
What's a pressure-breathing exercise?
The difference in usable consciousness between 26 and 32 was dramatic! About 2 min 15 at 26 before I started missing my coordination targets and reached for my mask. At 32, I kissed the floor 20 seconds after my mask came off. No warning tingles or wooziness, just "plop"!
Yikes, it seems the lesson is: "if in doubt, grab the oxygen mask"
Right after the chamber "touched down", they took us off the oxygen and sent us out to the "boom bucket" ejection seat trainer and the "Dilbert Dunker" cockpit submersion escape trainer.
I guess that does fairly accurately test judgement under adverse conditions: Bailouts are chaotic (if you survive it) and after that you still need to keep your head about you as you hit the water. At night, that's gotta be hard figuring out which way's up as you can barely see anything, in daytime you can at least see the bubbles, then there's that nice parachute that helped keep you from going splat, and now plans to drown you
 
What's a pressure-breathing exercise?
Yikes, it seems the lesson is: "if in doubt, grab the oxygen mask"
I guess that does fairly accurately test judgement under adverse conditions: Bailouts are chaotic (if you survive it) and after that you still need to keep your head about you as you hit the water. At night, that's gotta be hard figuring out which way's up as you can barely see anything, in daytime you can at least see the bubbles, then there's that nice parachute that helped keep you from going splat, and now plans to drown you
The danger of hypoxia is not when you have a task to do, it is when you don't. If you are trying to do something and cant, losing coordination etc then you may well think "Oxygen starvation" the real danger is when you are just sat doing nothing in particular and feeling drowsy, suddenly you are gone, like falling asleep at the wheel of a car. It is hard to believe you can fall asleep while driving a car or truck but many do. Perhaps the most dangerous part is that it isn't unpleasant, quite the opposite, people who have survived it describe a pleasant sleepy feeling, hypothermia sometimes does the same.
 
At one time B-17 crews carried bailout oxygen bottles. That practice had been discontinued when I was there. The training theory was when bailing out at altitude you may pass out during free fall but regain consciousness in time ( 10,000 to 15,000 ft, ) to activate the parachute. Scary business. We were also told to stay with aircraft as long as possible if under controlled decent.
 
Last edited:
I have been watching Air Disasters on the Smithsonian channel, mainly due to professional curiosity.
I've watched them (there were a series of books written by MacArthur Job as well) mostly out of curiosity, and being an aviation buff.

The saddest ones to read were the ones where there was essentially nothing that could have been done (short of the pilot calling in sick)
Some foreign airline professional airline pilots were inadequately trained on non-automatic flying techniques
It's sad that people use automation so much that they become incapable of doing anything on their own.
One airliner was lost because of the crew incompetently flew a non-precision approach (ILS was down, oh panic!) by drifting off course and descending BELOW the published minimum descent altitude (MDA) without having the runway in sight (could the runway not be seen because there was a hill in the way? Alas).
Was that the Crossair flight?
We flew worldwide routes into places like Addis Ababa and Tehran where the approaches were ADF (four ADF in the case of Tehran).
Those are the old radio-navaids with the needle pointing to the antenna, and using two to identify intersection points that form corridors?
The last example was the most baffling, the crash in 1999 of the Learjet 35 carrying the golfer Payne Stewart.
While I understand procedures are to be followed, I tend to try and find out what's written on paper, and what you actually do (they should be the same, but they aren't always...): I was always under the impression that if a depressurization occurs, first thing you do is grab the mask, turn on the oxygen, and then sort out anything else...
When the investigation group reviewed the published emergency procedures, donning the oxygen mask was not at the top of the list (I don't know if it was mentioned at all)!
It was in the list but it was like #8 or something...
AF and I assume Navy pilots
All military... frankly it should be extended to commercial aviation too, but it ain't gonna happen.

I loved the one on the Gimli Glider. We REALLY need to all convert to the metric system!
Yes, but it's vital to make sure you convert kilos to gallons, and gallons to liters right or you'll takeoff with half a tank. I'm amazed nobody noticed the plane was climbing really well...

Pacific Southwest 1771
Yeah, that was profoundly screwed up...
They changed screening rules after that.
For hiring or requiring everybody to go through the magnetometer?
My memory is that passengers on intrastate flights didn't have to go through pre-flight screening, and that this rule changed shortly after, but it may be that the passenger still had an airline ID and could bypass security.
No, the requirement was that employees could bypass screening, he was fired but due to a screw-up, they did not seize his ID...

Lots of theories with the DC-6 crash killing Hammarskjöld. His bodyguards were found with bullet wounds at the crash site. Wiki's explanation seems logical as to how the wounds were caused.
If the ammo would not have the power to penetrate a body, you could be looking at some kind of covert op: There are many zip-guns that do not have rifling...

And on that note (I'm taking this as inspiration from a buddy from another forum)
  • No matter how I die: It was murder -- even if there was a suicide note, even if there was a "suicide tape" or "suicide video" (those can be forged these days)
  • If I am arrested for a criminal offense: I didn't do it, no matter what evidence was shown to the contrary
  • If I disappear, it was not voluntary
:D

The Air Disasters series I have seen make me wonder about ever getting on an airliner again.
Yeah, but look how many planes takeoff and land just at one airport in one day without incident?
There was a VARIG 737 where the pilot and copilot read a flight plan for a course of 27.0 deg as being 270 deg and flew off into the setting sun until they ran out of fuel over the jungle and crashed. Their destination was almost due north and they flew into the setting sun
Amazing, you'd think the fact that they were flying into the sun would tip them off... I was driving today and had to keep fiddling with the visor because some of my route had me pointing into the sun

When my 2 oldest were flying from Vancouver to Prince George, an episode of "Mayday" was playing in one of the lounges. This didn't help my daughter who is petrified of flying

Hypoxia is almost exactly the same as Carbon Monoxide poisoning
Quite similar in some ways, they both deprive the brain of oxygen, but CO, HCN, KCN are actually worse as they not only bind to hemoglobin, but also disrupt the electron transport chain (that's the aerobic cycle that occurs inside the mitochondrion of our cells) which renders all of our cells anaerobic...
The danger of hypoxia is not when you have a task to do, it is when you don't.
Good point...
 
At one time B-17 crews carried bailout oxygen bottles. That practice had been discontinued when I was there. The training theory was when bailing out at altitude you may pass out during free fall but regain consciousness in time ( 10,000 to 15,000 ft, ) to activate the parachute. Scary business.
You know, I was thinking of something: The B-52's sometimes hit altitudes of 55,000 feet, as did some of the V-Bombers.

Since they didn't wear pressure-suits, how did they remain breathing after bailout?
 
The first fatal DC-3 crash - from a dropped microphone...

List of accidents and incidents involving the DC-3 in the 1930s - Wikipedia

img368.jpg
 
I guess that does fairly accurately test judgement under adverse conditions: Bailouts are chaotic (if you survive it) and after that you still need to keep your head about you as you hit the water. At night, that's gotta be hard figuring out which way's up as you can barely see anything, in daytime you can at least see the bubbles, then there's that nice parachute that helped keep you from going splat, and now plans to drown you
I think you misunderstood.
The Dilbert Dunker is not about bailouts, it's about going into the drink off the flight deck without time to punch out. They swaddle you in all the paraphernalia of a jet pilot and strap you into a cockpit on top of a ski-jump-like tower over a swimming pool. Then the cockpit runs down the skijump, dives into the pool, summersaults inverted, and sinks. You have to free yourself from all the straps, harnesses, and hookups, get yourself out of the cockpit, figure out where "up" is amidst the cloud of bubbles, and struggle to the surface. It's funny how the immediate bouyancy that makes it difficult to exit downward out of the inverted cockpit evaporates once you're headed upward, making it a struggle to surface. Makes you appreciate the safety diver hovering down there with his shroud cutter and Bowie knife.
Cheers
Wes
 
I think you misunderstood.
The Dilbert Dunker is not about bailouts, it's about going into the drink off the flight deck without time to punch out. They swaddle you in all the paraphernalia of a jet pilot and strap you into a cockpit on top of a ski-jump-like tower over a swimming pool. Then the cockpit runs down the skijump, dives into the pool, summersaults inverted, and sinks. You have to free yourself from all the straps, harnesses, and hookups, get yourself out of the cockpit, figure out where "up" is amidst the cloud of bubbles, and struggle to the surface. It's funny how the immediate bouyancy that makes it difficult to exit downward out of the inverted cockpit evaporates once you're headed upward, making it a struggle to surface. Makes you appreciate the safety diver hovering down there with his shroud cutter and Bowie knife.
Cheers
Wes
Sorry...............Bill
 
What's a pressure-breathing exercise?
Above approx 45K pressure altitude, even 100% O2 doesn't provide enough partial pressure of O2 for human survival, so if pressurization is lost, oxygen must be supplied to humans at pressure above ambient. This tends to inflate your chest like a balloon, and you have to struggle to exhale. Human musculature is designed to expand the chest while relaxing the muscles causes an exhale. Pressure breathing forces you to fight the pressure in order to exhale, a very tiring and claustrophobia inducing effort. I strained my very weak exhalation muscles in only 5 min at 46K, and my chest was sore for a week. Most of others in the chamber were highly fit fighter and attack pilots, and if I hadn't been doing a lot of scuba diving at the time, I would have wimped out.
Cheers,
Wes
 
Yikes, it seems the lesson is: "if in doubt, grab the oxygen mask"
Depressurization checklists for every pressurized aircraft I know of start with: "DON OXYGEN MASKS". I'm surprised that wasn't the case with the 1999 Learjet crash. I bet it is now.
The commuter airliner I used to fly was limited to FL250, but we practiced quick mask donning followed by an emergency descent procedure that would do justice to a JU87 or an SBD. (Mask on, power levers idle, props flat, at 200 knots one notch flaps, at 180 gear down, roll 80° left, let the nose fall through, roll wings level at 65-70° dive angle, stabilize at 180. Watch trees get bigger - fast!) We could get under 10K from FL250 in a little over 90 seconds. (At the cost of upsetting the passengers coffee!) Once established in the dive a cabin announcement was mandatory.
Cheers,
Wes
 
Last edited:
The B-52's sometimes hit altitudes of 55,000 feet, as did some of the V-Bombers.
Since they didn't wear pressure-suits, how did they remain breathing after bailout?
Don't know about V bombers, but the BUFF had downward firing ejection seats with barometric parachute openers usually set for the low teens in altitude. My ex-SAC acquaintances tell me the seat was equipped with a bailout bottle that fed the mask while the seat was free falling under a drogue chute down to whatever seat separation/parachute deployment altitude was set in the barometric opener.
Cheers,
Wes
 
I think you misunderstood.
I did.
They swaddle you in all the paraphernalia of a jet pilot and strap you into a cockpit on top of a ski-jump-like tower over a swimming pool. Then the cockpit runs down the skijump, dives into the pool, summersaults inverted, and sinks. You have to free yourself from all the straps, harnesses, and hookups, get yourself out of the cockpit, figure out where "up" is amidst the cloud of bubbles, and struggle to the surface.
Yikes... I guess whatever way the bubbles go, that's the way you should go. At night that's gotta be brutal.
Above approx 45K pressure altitude, even 100% O2 doesn't provide enough partial pressure of O2 for human survival, so if pressurization is lost, oxygen must be supplied to humans at pressure above ambient. This tends to inflate your chest like a balloon, and you have to struggle to exhale. Human musculature is designed to expand the chest while relaxing the muscles causes an exhale. Pressure breathing forces you to fight the pressure in order to exhale
It's like you can't get the air out fast enough, and you'd be wondering if your lungs are going to go pop from it. I don't know how it'd induce claustrophobia, but it sounds very uncomfortable.
Don't know about V bombers, but the BUFF had downward firing ejection seats with barometric parachute openers usually set for the low teens in altitude. My ex-SAC acquaintances tell me the seat was equipped with a bailout bottle that fed the mask while the seat was free falling under a drogue chute down to whatever seat separation/parachute deployment altitude was set in the barometric opener.
That sounds like it'd do it...
 
Yikes... I guess whatever way the bubbles go, that's the way you should go. At night that's gotta be brutal.
You can't exactly follow the bubbles because you have to swim away from the cockpit before surfacing to make sure you're well clear of the rapidly sinking aircraft and any fuel or hydraulic fluid it may have spread on the water.
There are a number of rather entertaining videos on YouTube under the search term "Dilbert Dunker". Most are from a couple decades more recent than my experience. I'm amazed at how much assistance these " modern" Dilberts are getting from the safety diver, how long it takes them to unstrap, and that they seem to have actual air in their mask/bottle. We had a dummy mask and bottle with no air or oxygen in it, and were drlled thoroughly on the unstrapping procedure, as we had to do it breath hold. (Five point strap release, O2 hose, G suit hose, audio cable, shed spurs, and heave out of the sticker clips.) The actual aircraft (not the Dunker) had an explosive guilotine that would release everything at once, but under water the bang would burst your eardrums and rattle your cage. We had a Dunker on base, and as the only scuba qualified guy in the detachment, guess who got to play safety diver? At least it was good for a free air tank refill courtesy of everybody's favorite rich uncle. Our Dunker was used rarely, as most aircrew needing recurrent certification needed the whole program, and we didn't have a boom bucket or an altitude chamber.
Cheers,
Wes
 
It's like you can't get the air out fast enough, and you'd be wondering if your lungs are going to go pop from it. I don't know how it'd induce claustrophobia, but it sounds very uncomfortable.
Don't worry, your lungs won't pop. The overpressure is regulated to a small amount above ambient, and the human ribcage is an amazingly strong structure.
The claustrophobia comes from the fact your mask is cinched tight to your helmet and it feels like your face is in a vise. This is necessary to keep the oxygen from leaking around the edges of your mask. It's called "having a good mask seal". That, plus you're straining to force out every exhale, and just as you get your lungs down to normal size, your aching muscles weaken, and suddenly you're a balloon again! Add that you're on the edge of hypoxia, and your vision is starting to tunnel and darken and the world is closing in on you, and your chest hurts and you want to rest but that incessant pressure won't let you, and panic is gnawing at the edges of your consciousness, but you're determined not to be the first to motion the chamber operator: "Enough! Take this thing down!". Sound like fun?
Cheers,
Wes
 
Quite similar in some ways, they both deprive the brain of oxygen, but CO, HCN, KCN are actually worse as they not only bind to hemoglobin, but also disrupt the electron transport chain (that's the aerobic cycle that occurs inside the mitochondrion of our cells) which renders all of our cells anaerobic...
Zipper, biology was my favourite and best subject at school, however our minds work in different ways. I would consider Hypoxia to be much worse. That is because if you are overcome by Carbon Monoxide you are not at 50,000ft and there is at least a chance of someone finding you and getting you to safety.
 
I did.
Yikes... I guess whatever way the bubbles go, that's the way you should go.

I read the same principle is applied when you're buried in an avalanche and ya don't know which way is up or down - dribble, and start digging in the opposite direction to the slag. :)
 
Read this in one of those fact books - seemed hard to believe, but it also directs the reader to the appropriate site where they got the info from...

More than half of British pilots fall asleep on the job, says report - AOL UK Travel

View attachment 480572
Been there, done that. 98% of my flying time was hand flown, but I did have a former student, a private business owner, who bought a tricked out Cessna turbo 210 and hired me to fly his people around and instruct any of them who wanted to get some stick time. This plane had a top of the line autopilot, area nav and flight management system, and flying became a matter of programming and monitoring rather than "driving the airplane". After three or four hours at FL230 unpressurized, with the nosebags on, the siren song of sleep became overwhelming. I would ask the guys in back to set their watch alarms to five minute repeat and check us in the front seats at each interval. As the only professional aviator in the bunch, I was the only one who couldn't afford one of those fancy dancy "aviator watches" that were so popular back then. Got woken up by ATC or the back seat guys on more than one occasion. Didn't help that the owner was a stickler for productivity, which meant long days, short nights, and multi day trips were the norm. Didn't have ALPA to fall back on, back then.
Cheers,
Wes
 
Last edited:

Users who are viewing this thread

Back