ThomasP
Senior Master Sergeant
Hey Propellorhead,
Once again, I have to ask you if you actually believe the stuff you are posting?
The problem(s) with the stuff you are posting - ie the details that prove the documents and anecdotal reports you have been posting are not true - is that none of the technical data is accurate. Don't feel too bad if you have been fooled, ignorance of the technical aspects (both in terms of the physics involved and in the manufacturing technology) needed to make atomic and nuclear warheads is quite common.
As I mentioned up-thread, the "Pinch" mechanism (sometimes referred to as "Z Pinch") design - supposedly patented by Schumann & Trinks in WWII and part of the reason the Germans could have had the A-bomb - could not possibly initiate an atomic or nuclear weapon. Also, in the purported Magic intercept you posted up-thread, it says the warheads were in the 5 kg range. It would not have been possible to produce a functional atomic warhead that small in WWII. And on top of that, you would have to have the ability to refine uranium and/or plutonium in the quantities needed. The only reason the US could refine enough material to make any bombs is due to the massive investment in the methods used to do so. None of the other countries involved in WWII dedicated the resources required - including the Germans.
Also, where are you getting this stuff? The reason I ask is that there is a group of people who post regularly on various websites, purporting to have information that no one else has, that is somehow supposed to prove that the Germans had the A-bomb in WWII.
They spend quite a lot of effort on their storyline in their attempts to fool the ignorant and weak-minded, including making up fake documents that are supposedly original source. They switch user names every so often, and sometimes talk (type) to each other on various forums (switching forums when they get booted off) as if they do not know each other, and in the process of their communication they present their data as if they are not coordinating with each other. If one storyline gets shot down often enough they switch to another variation on the theme. They have been doing this long enough that their behavior is becoming common knowledge amongst the denizens of the internet.
I would point out the specific technical errors but that would simply give information to the perpetrators of the "Magic" document you posted above, information that they could then regurgitate in their misinformation campaign.
Why do they do this? I can not say for sure, but this kind of behavior is usually an attempt at making the perpetrators feel better about themselves - the idea that they have fooled others into believing something that is not true apparently makes them feel superior - even when the people they have fooled are the ignorant or weak-minded.
Once again, I have to ask you if you actually believe the stuff you are posting?
The problem(s) with the stuff you are posting - ie the details that prove the documents and anecdotal reports you have been posting are not true - is that none of the technical data is accurate. Don't feel too bad if you have been fooled, ignorance of the technical aspects (both in terms of the physics involved and in the manufacturing technology) needed to make atomic and nuclear warheads is quite common.
As I mentioned up-thread, the "Pinch" mechanism (sometimes referred to as "Z Pinch") design - supposedly patented by Schumann & Trinks in WWII and part of the reason the Germans could have had the A-bomb - could not possibly initiate an atomic or nuclear weapon. Also, in the purported Magic intercept you posted up-thread, it says the warheads were in the 5 kg range. It would not have been possible to produce a functional atomic warhead that small in WWII. And on top of that, you would have to have the ability to refine uranium and/or plutonium in the quantities needed. The only reason the US could refine enough material to make any bombs is due to the massive investment in the methods used to do so. None of the other countries involved in WWII dedicated the resources required - including the Germans.
Also, where are you getting this stuff? The reason I ask is that there is a group of people who post regularly on various websites, purporting to have information that no one else has, that is somehow supposed to prove that the Germans had the A-bomb in WWII.
They spend quite a lot of effort on their storyline in their attempts to fool the ignorant and weak-minded, including making up fake documents that are supposedly original source. They switch user names every so often, and sometimes talk (type) to each other on various forums (switching forums when they get booted off) as if they do not know each other, and in the process of their communication they present their data as if they are not coordinating with each other. If one storyline gets shot down often enough they switch to another variation on the theme. They have been doing this long enough that their behavior is becoming common knowledge amongst the denizens of the internet.
I would point out the specific technical errors but that would simply give information to the perpetrators of the "Magic" document you posted above, information that they could then regurgitate in their misinformation campaign.
Why do they do this? I can not say for sure, but this kind of behavior is usually an attempt at making the perpetrators feel better about themselves - the idea that they have fooled others into believing something that is not true apparently makes them feel superior - even when the people they have fooled are the ignorant or weak-minded.
Last edited:
