Ad: This forum contains affiliate links to products on Amazon and eBay. More information in Terms and rules
You think that, but why?I think, and this is only my opinion, that the Soviets were not capable of repairing/rebuilding military complexes as fast as the Germans could. I also believe that in conjunction with destroying Soviets railroads, it would have been impossible in any reasonable time.
Nothing is proved, it's still a disputable question. I'm far from being sure that a strategic bombing is more effective than a blitskreag, leaded with the same means in Europe.Constant Strategic bombing is very effective, as the Americans proved.
German own losses are accurate enough, but their claims of kills are not very accurate. At the end of the day they are based on guesswork, like all claims.
What?
Russian sources are dodgy from the Soviet era, but I am fairly confident that good work was done from the latter part of the 80s plus there are some reasonable western sources now.
What accurate figures on losses. Why don't you use Krivosheiev's ones?Like I said, accurate figures on losses are hard to find, always disputed, and seldom accurate. that goes for both sides.
So on 1.1.43 VVS had 21 900 (a) planes on their own 12 300 in active army.
On 1.1.44 32 500/ 13 400 (b)
33 100 (c) were recieved both from industry and Lend Lease/ 22 500 (d) lost (total write -offs )
So i don't see any problem with this account: (a) + (c) -(d) = (b). No?
Have you got any approximate such a number for germans?
What's your problem and sources over Kuban?Kuban, awesome! as far as VVS claimes/losses, I would trust russian sources/documents as far as I could throw a Jak-9.
ie: untrustworthy.
German loss documents, well some are incomplete.. but unit diaries make up for that.
I think, and this is only my opinion, that the Soviets were not capable of repairing/rebuilding military complexes as fast as the Germans could.
relocated to existing factories? big difference I would think. so to avoid an arguement. I retract my statement " I think, and this is only my opinion, that the Soviets were not capable of repairing/rebuilding military complexes as fast as the Germans could."
When, in 1943 prior to Sicily and Kursk battles?
Or in summer (august) of 1944, when Ploesti was captured by soviets. Are you sure that strategic bombing campaign caused the fuel starvation, and not because german's had simply nothing else nothing to refine?
Regards