Did M4 Carbine Fail U.S. Troops During Afghanistan Assault?

Soren · Nov 22, 2009

Clay_Allison said:
We'll be stuck with the M4 or at best the M16 forever, the 5.56 too. This military is only interested in spending money on expensive toys, not the basics.

The G36 XM8 are both more expensive to manufacture than either the M4 or M16, and were turned down by the military because of this. But this was despite the fact that the G36 XM8 both displayed far superior performance than any AR15 design.

IMO the military should cough up the extra money and buy a rifle following the design of the G36 and chamber it in the 6.8mm round. That is what our boys need.

Some reading on the 6.8mm SPC round: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/6.8_mm_Remington_SPC

vikingBerserker · Nov 22, 2009

Very cool. Thanks for the education fellas!

Clay_Allison · Nov 23, 2009

Soren said:
The G36 XM8 are both more expensive to manufacture than either the M4 or M16, and were turned down by the military because of this. But this was despite the fact that the G36 XM8 both displayed far superior performance than any AR15 design.

IMO the military should cough up the extra money and buy a rifle following the design of the G36 and chamber it in the 6.8mm round. That is what our boys need.

Some reading on the 6.8mm SPC round: 6.8 mm Remington SPC - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Appreciate the link, but guns are my thing, I know the ballistics inside and out. I agree with you entirely, but the fact is that we will not do it, no matter how much we should.

lesofprimus · Nov 23, 2009

Gotta agree with both u guys.... Its downright blashphemous not to kit out our troops with the best product available...

Another reason why I used an AK whenever I had the chance....

Soren · Nov 25, 2009

Clay_Allison said:
Appreciate the link, but guns are my thing, I know the ballistics inside and out. I agree with you entirely, but the fact is that we will not do it, no matter how much we should.

Which is sad as heck. I truly believe that decisions such as these should be voted on within the military after a cost assessment has been made. It shouldn't be left up to some nimwit politician sitting at his desk eating cake whilst watching the news on CNN.

Did M4 Carbine Fail U.S. Troops During Afghanistan Assault?

More options

Soren

1st Lieutenant

vikingBerserker

Lieutenant General

Clay_Allison

Staff Sergeant

lesofprimus

Brigadier General

Soren

1st Lieutenant

Users who are viewing this thread

Similar threads